News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is IPv6 only for the Rich? [pdf] by lmm on Sunday May 13, 2018 @04:37PM (#17060922)
NAT is an annoyance. Peer-to-peer gaming or voicechat becomes laggy, or doesn't work at all. With the popular internet becoming more and more centralised, maybe it doesn't matter so much to the average end user, but there will come a point where people notice that gaming is better on ISP A than on ISP B even if you don't know exactly why.
Re:Is IPv6 only for the Rich? [pdf] by toyg on Sunday May 13, 2018 @04:56PM (#17061014)
Gaming is hardly a major driver of infrastructure choices, with all due respect.

The issue is that most businesses are now so well-acquainted with NAT-ting, they don't really care for IP addresses. In fact, the more opaque your network topology is to the outside, the better from a security point of view. Every app works through http these days (because proxies are mandatory, again for security), so there is little need for real addresses.

Re:Is IPv6 only for the Rich? [pdf] by lmm on Sunday May 13, 2018 @05:10PM (#17061067)
> Gaming is hardly a major driver of infrastructure choices, with all due respect.

When it comes to consumer ISPs, who are the people paying for the high-end packages?

> The issue is that most businesses are now so well-acquainted with NAT-ting, they don't really care for IP addresses. In fact, the more opaque your network topology is to the outside, the better from a security point of view. Every app works through http these days (because proxies are mandatory, again for security), so there is little need for real addresses.

Existing large businesses are happy with their current ways of doing things, sure. But those have never been the early adopters. IPv6 suits the startups (anyone who's working with containers hits problems from reusing the same subnets sooner or later) and it suits businesses that have to merge existing networks. No-one wants to be first, but there will come a point where the IPv4 costs are high enough to be worth doing something about.

Re:Is IPv6 only for the Rich? [pdf] by dx034 on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:10AM (#17064733)
> When it comes to consumer ISPs, who are the people paying for the high-end packages?

A family of 5 where you need the bandwidth if everyone starts streaming videos at the same time. For gaming you'd advertise ping times, I haven't really seen that recently.

Re:Is IPv6 only for the Rich? [pdf] by toyg on Monday May 14, 2018 @04:22AM (#17063773)
> IPv6 suits the startups

That matches what the presentation says: IPv6 is growing roughly as the internet grows, i.e. new ISPs go with it, because if you are starting from scratch, might as well do things in the modern way. (If you mean vanilla web startup, I think they have enough problems without risking to bork things up by misconfiguring a feature nobody really asks for...)

> When it comes to consumer ISPs, who are the people paying for the high-end packages?

Movie watchers and other media addicts; and they don't really care about IP addresses.

IMHO a lot of bigger ISPs have looked at the struggles of early adopters and decided the effort is not worth it. Most of their budgets these days go towards traffic shaping and caching, where IPv6 doesn't really help much. Established businesses are not clamouring for the feature, so why bother?

I agree that at some point things will change. I think the point of the article was that we thought we had reached that threshold a few years ago, but it looks like it wasn't really the case.

Re:Is IPv6 only for the Rich? [pdf] by tormeh on Sunday May 13, 2018 @08:05PM (#17061761)
>anyone who's working with containers hits problems from reusing the same subnets sooner or later

Docker doesn't support IPv6, I think.

Re:Is IPv6 only for the Rich? [pdf] by lokedhs on Sunday May 13, 2018 @09:29PM (#17062044)
It does, but it's disabled by default. Note that this option is about using IPv6 internally between containers. Even with it off, any exposed port will be both IPv4 and IPv6.
Re:Is IPv6 only for the Rich? [pdf] by ec109685 on Monday May 14, 2018 @12:28AM (#17062689)
There are millions of private ipv4 addresses available. Can you talk about how subnet reuse becomes a problem?
Re:Is IPv6 only for the Rich? [pdf] by Arnt on Monday May 14, 2018 @11:35AM (#17066364)
Too many people use 192.168.0/24 and 192.168.1/24 and eventually some of those networks need to be connected. You can only have so many of those in an organisation before it becomes a pain point.

A conslutant friend told a story about a customer who had been through a few mergers and demergers. One nightly database dump there involved parts of one database being copied to another, both internal to the same company, through five layers of NAT. One of the routers had a 1500-line NAT configuration.

Re:Is IPv6 only for the Rich? [pdf] by ahbs66 on Sunday May 13, 2018 @10:56PM (#17062353)
>When it comes to consumer ISPs, who are the people paying for the high-end packages?

Gamers don't need high speed or thousands of services and telly channels, just good ping

Re:Is IPv6 only for the Rich? [pdf] by ahbs66 on Sunday May 13, 2018 @04:49PM (#17060981)
>Peer-to-peer gaming or voicechat becomes laggy, or doesn't work at all.

It's 2018, nobody would be insane enough to try that

Re:Is IPv6 only for the Rich? [pdf] by zaarn on Monday May 14, 2018 @04:25AM (#17063790)
Ghost Recon Wildlands, a 2017 Game, uses P2P game lobbies.

It's still very popular because it's cheaper; no expensive servers to run for customers and they can still play if you eventually shut down your services.

Re:Is IPv6 only for the Rich? [pdf] by lmm on Sunday May 13, 2018 @05:14PM (#17061077)
Maybe not the big names, but it's still happening. I have at least one new-in-2018 game that I had to do some port forwarding for (Heart of Crown).