That's somewhat true only in a very narrow world of USA and ISIS. In most of the world, nationalism is based on very different terms.
> One step this way, I love them; one step the other way, I oppose them? It's absurd.
Nah. Nationalism doesn't mean opposing anybody. It's belonging to community and working for it's greater good.
> Finally, nationalism is an obsession of a small group imposed on others.
Most people don't care about any political, societal or any other philosophical discourses. They just follow few people who are interested in that kind of stuff. As far as I looked all revolutions were imposed by a small group of concerned citizens on the rest of the community. I'm yet to find an exception where majority people truly believed in the original idea from day 1. They just followed people who seemed worthy.
In both cases they effectively ended oppression and brutality. In most cases, it was direct result of ethnic hatred towards those people who called themselves nationalists.
Humans naturally gravitate towards tribalism. We're simply not capable to feel connected to every human on planet earth. Nationalism is probably one of the better and more sustainable forms of tribalism. Definitely better than highly polarised or multi-cultural (which is totally different from multi-ethnic or multi-racial) societies.
Most of what you listed if chauvinism, not nationalism. On the other hand, I don't see anything wrong if society wants to stay (not become) homogenous. It's easier to come to social contract that way. Which is the most important for healthy society.
Human have lots of bad instincts - violence, war, hatred, greed, etc etc - but history shows beyond a doubt that we overcome them and it works astoundingly well. But we've overcome those things and built democracies, liberty, a world where violence and war is at historic laws, lifespans are probably double what they were for most of history, women are in the workforce, we walk on the moon, human rights and prosperity have expanded by orders of magnitude. All of that came from the embrace of universal rights and liberty.
> We're simply not capable ...
In fact, we certainly are!
The question is, why would anyone want to take away all that success and ruin it?
Yes, yes, end of history and all that jazz. Yet greed is at all time high. We had a couple attempts at that in 20th century and it didn't went well at all. Hatred and violence are still strong. I'm
A lot of things you listed were done in societies that didn't fully embrace liberty/democracy/universal rights. USSR or commie China or Japan or Singapore. Western civilisation that did fully embrace them built their prosperity without any of those things and now just run on their former glory.
Walking on the moon was possible specifically because of war effort.
> > We're simply not capable ... > In fact, we certainly are!
Dunbar number. Anything above that needs a super simple approach to keep people together. Greece crises was a fantastic example. Lots of people were against bail out. Meanwhile they were pissed others don't want to help them too. If fellow europeans don't feel strong connection, I doubt they'd truly feel it for culturally much more different people on the other side of the globe.
> The question is, why would anyone want to take away all that success and ruin it?
What success? The success to not be able to keep population at replacement levels? Rampant mental illnesses? All that while democracy support is at 50 years low, liberty is in danger and people are too afraid of violence and war to solve any problem?
Oh and it's been a while since we were on the moon and it doesn't look like it's happening any time soon...
They do?
> You can read people advocating it in HN, just like you can read many attempts to whitewash it.
> if you accept the nationalist argument that 'people on my side have rights and those on the other don't'
> We've had enough slavery, segregation, Holocausts, Tutsi massacres, Milosovic's, ISIS's, oppression of women, Nazis, etc, etc. to know how it turns out; we don't need to try again and hope it's different this time.
(I might as well excerpt your entire post, it is the perfect embodiment of my confusion on this topic. As are the rising downvotes, arguably proving my point and censoring my voice, as I will now have to leave this tab open and wait to post my sincere rebuttal later. Freedom of speech is a great principle until it disagrees with your ideas I guess.)
I gave you a definition of nationalism from the dictionary, I will ask you once again: what definition are you using for the word nationalism?
Going further, what is the origin of the various extreme beliefs & hatred you hold? Where did you learn these ideas?
The endlessly repeated lesson of history is that if human rights are not universal, if you accept the nationalist argument that 'people on my side have rights and those on the other don't', then it ends up justifying denying rights to any person or group, and the brutality that follows. That's why the foundation of the United States is universal human rights, 'all men are created equal and endowed ... with inalienable rights'. We've had enough slavery, segregation, Holocausts, Tutsi massacres, Milosovic's, ISIS's, oppression of women, Nazis, etc, etc. to know how it turns out; we don't need to try again and hope it's different this time.
In contrast, universal human rights as the basis of the post-WWII order has provided the greatest expansion of freedom and prosperity in human history, with no comparison. Why would anyone want to give that up? Why are we looking for ways to divide people and to justify and whitewash hate?
What is the basis of nationalism? That a human being's rights and my regard from them depend on an imaginary line on the earth? One step this way, I love them; one step the other way, I oppose them? It's absurd.
Finally, nationalism is an obsession of a small group imposed on others. The nationalists say all white Christian people are part of their nation, but a most of those people don't see it that way. Certain nationalists claim me as part of their 'nation', but I abhor and oppose them and certainly am not a member. Nationalists are a small group of people who, just like the tyrants and evil people before them, simply try to impose their will on others. I believe the others should live free.