News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Matt Maroon: The Anti-Social Graph by aston on Tuesday April 22, 2008 @10:49AM (#170584)
There're only two questions that are important for trying to put a price on Facebook:

  1) How much are Facebook users worth to advertisers (brand and/or CPC) on average and in aggregate?

  2) How much is the data Facebook has (the social graph, demographic information) worth to third parties?
Matt's answer to both, based on his recent two articles, is "right now, not much relative to the internet heavyweights." That actually isn't controversial at all.

There's a lot of optimism about Facebook's future, however, that allows people to argue against Matt based on the "just wait until you see what they come up with" line of reasoning.

I'd be interested in hearing from both sides about this future Facebook. As in, what facts, specifically, might change about the world that would make Facebook worth $15 billion, and how likely is it that those changes will come about?

Re:Matt Maroon: The Anti-Social Graph by cstejerean on Tuesday April 22, 2008 @11:47AM (#170644)
so facebook has nowhere to go but down. if they do find a magical solution they get to keep their 15 billion valuation (since the valuation is based on them finding said solution), but if they fail their value will drop rapidly to several hundred million at best. not the kind of bet I would want to make as an investor.
Re:Matt Maroon: The Anti-Social Graph by fleaflicker on Tuesday April 22, 2008 @04:36PM (#170922)
Facebook's users aren't valuable to advertisers because they're "fragmented" (i.e., no common interests).

That's why the only ads you see on MySpace and Facebook are for dating sites and T-shirts.

The bigger money is in selling very specific advertising (for example, selling HD-TVs to fantasy football fanatics).

Re:Matt Maroon: The Anti-Social Graph by anewaccountname on Tuesday April 22, 2008 @10:00PM (#171198)
I just searched, and there are 15,321 groups with "fantasy football" in the title on Facebook.
Re:Matt Maroon: The Anti-Social Graph by Goladus on Tuesday April 22, 2008 @03:13PM (#170847)
There's a third question, though, with regard to optimism about Facebook's future, and that's the quality of its end-user experience and the likelihood it will retain its current users and traffic and continue growing.