News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Build your own X: project-based programming tutorials by DonHopkins on Saturday May 12, 2018 @06:47PM (#17056423)
I agree, it would have been such an unpleasant surprise to see another implementation of X-Windows! ;)

https://medium.com/@donhopkins/the-x-windows-disaster-128d39...

Re:Build your own X: project-based programming tutorials by carapace on Saturday May 12, 2018 @11:02PM (#17057177)
On a tangent, the NSA put out a paper long long ago on X Windows security. (I don't think it was this on but it might have been: "Securing The X Window System With SELinux" [1]) Do you happen to know the one?

I'd also like to thank you for turning me on to NeWS et. al. ages ago in another forum. Blew my mind because at the time I only really knew about MS Windows and X. Cheers!

[1] https://www.nsa.gov/resources/everyone/digital-media-center/...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NeWS

Re:Build your own X: project-based programming tutorials by ronsor on Saturday May 12, 2018 @07:11PM (#17056500)
Actually a less unwieldy implementation of X11 would be nice. Preferably in Go or Rust.
Re:Build your own X: project-based programming tutorials by earenndil on Sunday May 13, 2018 @06:09PM (#17061294)
Why go _OR_ rust? Those are completely different languages with completely different goals and almost nothing in common.
Re:Build your own X: project-based programming tutorials by DonHopkins on Saturday May 12, 2018 @07:16PM (#17056516)
Hasn't somebody reimplemented X11 in JavaScript/canvas/websockets yet?

There was an X11 server for Lisp Machines! Not sure who wrote it, but it was probably written inside or at least nearby the X Consortium, and I remember Robert Scheifler used it regularly.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6864364

"For example the TI Explorer Lisp Machine came with an X11 server written in Lisp. On my Symbolics Lisp Machine I used the usual MIT X11 server written in C - this was possible because the Symbolics Lisp machine had a C compiler." -lispm

John Steinhart wrote XTool, a nice snappy reimplementation of X11 on top of SunView! ;)

https://minnie.tuhs.org//pipermail/tuhs/2017-September/01047...

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15325226

>XTool was very small and fast compared to the X sample server because I wrote the server from scratch. I think that I'm the only person to write an X server outside of the X Consortium. One of the things that I learned by doing it was that the X Consortium folks were wrong when they said that the documentation was the standard, not the sample server. There were significant differences between the two.

>The only really worthwhile thing about X was the distributed extension registration mechanism. All of the input, graphics and other crap should be moved to extension #1. That way, it won't be mandatory in conforming implementations once that stuff was obsolete. As you probably know, that's where we are today; nobody uses that stuff but it's like the corner of an Intel chip that implements the original instruction set. As an aside, I upset many when working on OpenDoc for Apple and saying the same thing there.

>The atom/property mechanism allows clients to allocate memory in the server that can never be freed. Some way to free memory needs to be added.

>The bit encodings should be part of a separate language binding, not part of the functional description.

>Had he done some real design work and looked at what others were doing he might have realized that at its core, X was a distributed database system in which operations on some of the databases have visual side-effects. I forget the exact number, but X includes around 20 different databases: atoms, properties, contexts, selections, keymaps, etc. each with their own set of API calls. As a result, the X API is wide and shallow like the Mac, and full of interesting race conditions to boot. The whole thing could have been done with less than a dozen API calls.

Re:Build your own X: project-based programming tutorials by jacobush on Saturday May 12, 2018 @07:12PM (#17056501)
Would it be X11 then?