News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by Bucephalus355 on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:27PM (#17049202)
During World War II, there were tons of issues with the healthiness of recruits. Sadly, this was because of all the malnutrition of children (and adults) that occurred during The Depression.

This did not really effect the war effort during WWII. Fascinatingly, the US never really fully mobilized for WWII, and could have easily fielded an output 2-3x higher than it did. One of the more famous pieces of data is a survey at the end of the war that asked “did you feel you had to make significant sacrifices in your life or living style during the war”. 7 out of 10 said no.

Also, the US has always ramped up INCREDIBLY quickly during war. It’s a testament to the latent, incredible power of democracies. For example, it was just 6 months between Pearl Harbor and the Battle of Midway, where 4 Japanese aircraft carriers were sunk and hundreds of planes / pilots destroyed.

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by neffy on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:44PM (#17049348)
To be completely fair about this, the US was ramping up a long time before Pearl Harbour. (This is part of the extended discussion around the attack itself, and whether it should have been anticipated.) British rearming began in 1936, the US was certainly planning in the late 30´s, actual spending began in 1939, and ramped up quickly after that during 1940.

In war, as in many other things, if you want to ride the wave, you have to be ready long before you see it coming.

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by jcranmer on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:06PM (#17050018)
It is good policy for any military to work out plans for various kinds of war. Even during extreme pacifism days in the 1930s, the US had contingency plans for wars with Germany (War Plan Black), Britain (War Plan Red, with different shades of red for different colonies), Japan (War Plan Orange).

In WWI, it took about a year for the US army to ramp up involvement in the war effort following its entry. There was thus a recognition by 1939 that the US needed to prepare for war or similarly spend a long time ramping up. In 1940, FDR authorized the draft, and throughout 1940 and 1941, the US strained the definition of neutrality to its breaking point, particularly as cash-and-carry (we'll only sell to people who can pay in gold) gave way to lend-lease (we'll only sell to countries named Great Britain or the Soviet Union, and we offer a 60-year payment plan).

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by travmatt on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:54PM (#17049435)
Roosevelt definitely saw the war coming and prepared for it. He was hampered by the strong isolationist feelings at the time but he never gave in to them, and was careful never to run too far ahead of public opinion.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by ethbro on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:21PM (#17049645)
The Washington Naval Treaty [1] was also in effect until 1937, limiting new naval construction.

I think the original point is valid, subject to the vagaries of international agreements at the time.

The production dates and rate of the Essex class [2] were simply ridiculous... (said as someone whose grandfather worked at Newport News during the war)

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Washington_Naval_Treaty

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Essex-class_aircraft_carrier#S...

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by Andre_Wanglin on Friday May 11, 2018 @06:39PM (#17051231)
Roosevelt saw the war coming because he wanted it to come and engineered a way for the US to be attacked (the US way of war has alway been to provoke and goad the other side into firing first [or outright faking such a provocation] then feigning moral outrage) and overcome these (sensible) sentiments. The "isolationist" strain of US diplomacy was part of its founding ethos and WW2 was responsible for obliterating it from the American identity. Was this really a good thing?
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by travmatt on Friday May 11, 2018 @09:03PM (#17051874)
Seeing as those same America First party people are the same strains of America trying to sell the upside of neo-nazism, I’m going to go with yes? Sorry I’m not edgy enough to sell myself on the upsides of racial and ethnic cleansing...
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by Andre_Wanglin on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:50PM (#17052391)
Seeing as how those America First people are the ones who came around to fighting and defeating the Nazis, that's quite a disgusting and loaded remark. It is a shibboleth among the alt-right that they are called Nazis by people like you for sharing beliefs of their grandfathers who fought Nazis and you are reinforcing that perception.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by threepipeproblm on Saturday May 12, 2018 @10:25AM (#17054194)
But not a disgusting remark like when you stated that 'the "genocide" of native Americans was a result of European diseases, not barbarism' in another thread and argued that evidence of deliberate killing was more like a "rounding error". https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17023220 Not disgusting like that, right?
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by Andre_Wanglin on Saturday May 12, 2018 @03:35PM (#17055634)
Yes, that's right.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by philwelch on Friday May 11, 2018 @06:51PM (#17051286)
You’re right, we should have just let Germany, Japan, and maybe Stalinist Russia split up the rest of the world between themselves. That definitely would have worked out fine and they never would have bothered us. Hitler’s not so bad once you get to know him...
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by maoistinquisitr on Friday May 11, 2018 @09:05PM (#17051879)
Well look how communism in Asia played out over the ensuing 40 years. Would it have been such a horrible idea to let Japanese boys die fighting off communists? And why are 50+K American lives still at stake (and billions of dollars in defense spending) policing the region?

We should have worked with the Japanese and had them mostly run the place.

> Hitler’s not so bad once you get to know him

Agreed.

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by philwelch on Friday May 11, 2018 @09:18PM (#17051937)
I feel compelled to point out that I was being sarcastic about Hitler.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by Andre_Wanglin on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:41PM (#17052369)
Would there have been a "Holocaust" without the war? What would the fate of the interned Japanese in the US have been should the mainland have come under massive bombardment and firebombing that left the populace barely able to eat?
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by hungerstrike on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:33PM (#17049733)
I read that we stopped supplying steel to Japan which caused them to attack us.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by AnimalMuppet on Friday May 11, 2018 @06:41PM (#17051234)
Caused? No. It was one of the reasons they chose to do so, but that's not the same thing.

And why did we stop selling them steel? Because we didn't approve of them invading China and massacring people.

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by hungerstrike on Saturday May 12, 2018 @11:39AM (#17054535)
So if I slap you in the face and you punch me...my slap didn’t cause it? K.

In wartime, when your neutral, you’re supposed to supply all sides or nobody. Who made US protector of the world?

Meanwhile George Bushes grand daddy was funding the Nazis with his bank.

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by d0ugie on Sunday May 13, 2018 @10:09PM (#17062201)
You mean in retrospect? Or was that the prevailing opinion of citizens at the time that had anything to do with trade or total war?
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by Retric on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:51PM (#17049897)
Not just ramping up, but we also had fairly direct involvement. 'Lend-Lease' occurred before Pearl Harbor providing large amounts of military and non military aid and had a significant impact.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by neffy on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:25PM (#17050155)
Very much so. In Churchill's war diaries there's this great begging letter to Roosevelt early on in the war, which basically says, for God's sake, send rifles now. After Dunkirk, the UK didn't have enough to even arm the men they had in the army, never mind the home guard and reserves. Then there were the shipments to Russia. The Allies could never have won the war without the US's incredible production capacity.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by seem_2211 on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:31PM (#17050211)
It's pretty interesting actually - I'm reading The Last Lion (a biography of Winston Churchill), and it's amazing how much the British appeased Hitler and neglected to rearm, while the Nazis built out a serious army. But then to imagine the current mood for American intervention in Syria being championed by someone like Donald Rumsfeld and it's perhaps a little easier to understand, with Churchill being blamed for a lot of the loss of life in WW1.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by jcranmer on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:16PM (#17050101)
The speedy US ramp up in WWII is illusory, because the US essentially entered the war effort in 1940, well before its official entry in 1941.

That said, logistics has long been one of the core competencies of the US. As far back as the American Revolution, Henry Knox transported captured cannon at Fort Ticonderoga to Boston--in the middle of winter--and then installed them in a single night on Dorchester Heights, which forced the British evacuation of Boston. The Americans also managed a major supply route to China via an aerial airlift (The Hump), which became the template for supplying Berlin via airlift--something most military planners thought completely impossible until the British and the Americans pulled it off.

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by philwelch on Friday May 11, 2018 @06:58PM (#17051320)
A lot of the US production numbers peak in 1943/1944, though, and even then, only because we thoroughly outgunned the Axis and didn’t actually need to keep producing at that rate. The amount of ramp up that was politically possible in 1940 was nothing close to what the US was capable of.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by megaman22 on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @05:04AM (#17080956)
Most of German manpower and materiel was bled out on the steppes of Russia - even the greatest threat to the ETO (Battle of the Bulge) was a sideshow in the grand scheme of things, compared to even the shadow of the Wehrmacht that was still fighting in Poland and Hungary at the same time.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by philwelch on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:11PM (#17049574)
I've found this to be a fascinating breakdown of the US's production capacity advantage in WWII: http://www.combinedfleet.com/economic.htm

> America, even in the midst of seemingly interminable economic doldrums, still had:

* Nearly twice the population of Japan.

* Seventeen time's Japan's national income.

* Five times more steel production.

* Seven times more coal production.

* Eighty (80) times the automobile production.

> Furthermore, America had some hidden advantages that didn't show up directly in production figures....the per capita productivity of the American worker was the highest in the world. Furthermore, the United States was more than willing to utilize American women in the war effort....The net effect of all these factors meant that even in the depths of the Depression, American war-making potential was still around seven times larger than Japan's, and had the 'slack' been taken out in 1939, it was closer to nine or ten times as great!

> ...

> By 1944, most of the other powers in the war, though still producing furiously, were beginning to max out their economies (i.e. production was stabilizing or plateauing). This resulted from destruction of industrial bases and constriction of resource pools (in the case of Germany and Japan), or through sheer exhaustion of manpower (in the case of Great Britain and, to an extent, the USSR). By contrast, the United States suffered from none of these difficulties, and as a consequence its economy grew at an annual rate of 15% throughout the war years. As scary as it sounds, by the end of the war, the United States was really just beginning to get 'warmed up.' It is perhaps not surprising that in 1945, the U.S. accounted for over 50% of total global GNP.

> ...

> But it is no joke to say that we were literally building ships faster than anybody could sink them, and still have enough left over to carry mountains of material to the most God-forsaken, desolate stretches of the Pacific. Those Polynesian cargo cults didn't start for no reason, and it was American merchant vessels in their thousands which delivered the majority of this seemingly divinely profligate largesse to backwaters which had probably never seen so much as a can opener before.

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by jcranmer on Friday May 11, 2018 @04:31PM (#17050600)
The major change to the US economy was the mass movement of (mostly black) labor from inefficient small-scale farming to industrial manufacturing. Effectively, when the factories ran out of white males, they turned to black males, and later females of all colors, to provide the manpower to keep them going. The German war production was largely being staffed by French and Belgian workers in more or less slavery rather than adopting German women into the workforce.

Another key difference is that Germany rationed differently based on nationality. Germans in the home front were allotted about 2000 calories per day, even in 1945 when the country was falling apart. The factory workers in occupied territories were allotted only about 1300 calories per day, while their compatriots not in labor got closer to 1000 calories per day. The standard US civilian rations were perhaps 3000 calories per day. I think UK civilian rations were around 1800 calories per day. When the people making your war materiel are basically starving, it's no wonder they're less productive.

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by greedo on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:39PM (#17050283)
The average Liberty ship took 42 days to build. 42 days. That's an incredible display of industrial power.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by jshaqaw on Friday May 11, 2018 @08:51PM (#17051823)
And now it takes a year to do basic sewer repairs on my NYC Street. What happened!
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by billfruit on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:04PM (#17049515)
But I think US ability to organize and deploy faster is something that has materialized after army reforms around 1900-1905, as I understand from Barbara Tuchman biography of General Stillwell. It appears US had major trouble in managing a speedy mobilization in the Spanish American war, and so it does not alwyas imply that democracies have inherent capability to mobilize troops faster.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by WalterBright on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:16PM (#17049610)
> incredible power of democracies

I'd say free markets. The US was able to handily fight two wars (against Japan and Germany) as well as massively supplying Britain and the Soviet Union.

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by _yosefk on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:04PM (#17050000)
What's the difference between France (lost quickly in WWII), Britain (barely evaded invasion), and the US (not invaded, economy grew during the war)? Is it democracy, free markets, or accessibility to German tanks and war planes that is the likely reason for the difference?

8 out of 10 Germans losses were inflicted by the Soviet Army; the USSR didn't rank high on democracy or market freedom but it had no choice but fight Germany, whereas the US could afford to choose the extent of engagement and let the USSR (and Britain) bleed while inflicting losses on Germany. This is not to say that the US policy wasn't sensible for the US, just that WWII is not a clear testament to the latent strengths of democracies and free markets at waging war.

And on the point of democracy specifically, in "The Gathering Storm," Churchill nearly pins the breakout of WWII on the inherent difficulty of conducting sensible foreign policy under democracy (both in the case of the badly designed peace treaties at the end of WWI, and in the case of subsequent appeasement of Nazi Germany.)

I wouldn't want to live where they don't have democracy or a reasonably free market, but neither is a reliable device to either prevent or win a world war.

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by passivepinetree on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:23PM (#17050143)
> What's the difference between France (lost quickly in WWII), Britain (barely evaded invasion), and the US (not invaded, economy grew during the war)?

A lot of it is location, to be honest. Invading the U.S. was nowhere near as easy as invading France, Poland, etc. for Germany (or Japan, for that matter).

I think the closest we got to invasion during the war (outside Pearl Harbor) were some isolated submarines off the coast of Oregon: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombardment_of_Fort_Stevens

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by DrScump on Saturday May 12, 2018 @03:58AM (#17052985)
Several Aleutian Islanda were taken over by the Japanese, as were Wake, Guam, and the Philippines.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by philwelch on Friday May 11, 2018 @07:07PM (#17051359)
The USSR was largely dependent upon US support for food and industry.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by maoistinquisitr on Friday May 11, 2018 @08:59PM (#17051859)
> US (not invaded, economy grew during the war

GDP grew during the war due to federal debt. The standard of living markedly declined and didn't recover until much later.

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by greedo on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:40PM (#17050293)
France and Great Britain never really recovered from the losses incurred during WW1. Not just financially, but in losing a generation of men in their prime.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by philwelch on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:18PM (#17049625)
...and simultaneously invent the atom bomb.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by maoistinquisitr on Friday May 11, 2018 @08:55PM (#17051840)
Japan and Germany fought WWII because they wanted to secure oil supplies. The USSR and USA defeated them because they had massive amounts of oil at their disposal. The USA was #1 producer at the time. Also, both the Germans and Japanese failed to secure oil supplies and refineries quickly enough and quickly ran out of liquid fuels. WWII can almost be boiled down to this factor alone. If Germany and Japan had secured supplies of liquid fuels they would not have been defeated. Democracy and capitalism has nothing to do with it.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by WalterBright on Saturday May 12, 2018 @05:07AM (#17053158)
Even in the early stages of the Pacific war, the Japanese soldier was very lightly equipped and the Japanese could not replace their losses, while the US produced a tsunami of equipment and supplies starting from near zero at the outset.

You'll see the impact of free markets even in the Civil War. The Southern slave economy could not produce what was needed - they couldn't even produce shoes for their soldiers. The free Northern economy buried them with well equipped well fed soldiers. (The North and South were both democracies. Slave/free economies made the difference.)

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by maoistinquisitr on Saturday May 12, 2018 @11:07AM (#17054375)
Both German and Russian war production increased throughout the war under command economies and massive bombing. They key factor was fuel.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by zantana on Friday May 11, 2018 @06:35PM (#17051212)
I am always surprised that people analogize moonshot as the ultimate national effort opposite WWII.

Despite noir movies like Double Indemnity, which don't seem to show any effects at all, reading about it, it always seems that WWII effected practically every part of life down to the steel penny.

Whereas despite the "let them eat moonshot" quip from Asimov I haven't heard of great initiatives which didn't take place because of the space race.

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by philwelch on Friday May 11, 2018 @06:45PM (#17051258)
The Manhattan Project alone is close to the scale of the moonshot, and the US was devoting so many resources to the war that virtually no one even noticed that the Manhattan Project was happening. Not even Vice President Truman knew about it until after FDR’s death.
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by 15charlimitdumb on Friday May 11, 2018 @07:40PM (#17051500)
Interesting note on WW2 expenditures, the B-29 Superfortress actually cost more than the Manhattan project. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_B-29_Superfortress

"Including design and production, at over $3 billion it was the single most expensive weapons project undertaken by the United States in World War II, exceeding the cost of the Manhattan Project by between $1 and 1.7 billion"

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by philwelch on Friday May 11, 2018 @09:26PM (#17051971)
I'm curious about how that happened, honestly. Was there a "second-system effect" that settled in after the B-17?
Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by olegious on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:02PM (#17049990)
> incredible power of democracies

I think it helped that the war wasn't fought on American soil (outside of Pearl Harbor, obviously). This means the homeland, industrial capacity and transport systems weren't disrupted.

Re:Why dumb recruits cost the Army, big-time (2006) by s2g on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:38PM (#17050275)
> For example, it was just 6 months between Pearl Harbor and the Battle of Midway, where 4 Japanese aircraft carriers were sunk and hundreds of planes / pilots destroyed.

Part of that was that Pearl Harbour didn't really accomplish the strategic goals. The US didn't lose nearly enough to cripple them.