News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by prepend on Friday May 11, 2018 @12:25PM (#17048625)
I like how they talk about “Mr. A” using his interview with Thiel to pitch the conspiracy rather than a startup. An aspect not covered in the book.

This podcast made me read the book. The book is interesting, but this podcast is somehow better because of the way Roberts questions Holiday down a few logical paths.

Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by kbuchanan on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:03PM (#17049507)
I also read the book. It's a bit overwrought with classical quotes and psychological exploration. Don't get me wrong, I love the classics, but I often wanted the book to get on with the details of the story.
Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by s73v3r_ on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:15PM (#17049088)
That truly was a case in which there was no good side to it. There was nobody worth rooting for, and no matter who won, it would have been bad. Publishing a private citizen's sex tape is not news, and for that matter, neither is outing someone who is not wanting to be outed. Using your vast wealth to bankroll someone else's lawsuit is also quite shady.
Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by sjansen on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:03PM (#17049509)
Agreed. Every time someone expresses outrage at the lawsuit, I want to ask them why Gawker gets a free pass for their behavior. The truth is, they sealed their own fate by stepping outside the bounds of both law and civility.
Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by oculusthrift on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:26PM (#17049676)
Well the entire media coverage of the event was on Gawkers side because the media wants to be able to print anything. Therefore if you hadn’t investigated further i could see why you would take Gawkers side.
Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Friday May 11, 2018 @05:47PM (#17050997)
Not just that, a lot of the media that wrote about it had close friends or sometimes even family members that were employees of Gawker.
Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by drspacemonkey on Friday May 11, 2018 @04:51PM (#17050705)
Hell, it's even worse than that. "Sex tape" implies Hogan and a ladyfriend set up a camera and put on a show.

They were recorded having sex via hidden camera, without their knowledge or consent. That's a sex crime that they treated like it was leaked nude selfies.

Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by bad_ramen_soup on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:27PM (#17049199)
I'm curious how stoicism is tied to this as Holiday has been using his Daily Stoic platform to promote this book as well..
Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by knuththetruth on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:00PM (#17049484)
It’s not really. Holiday has always been a “finger to the wind” public intellectual. Stoicism isn’t really a marketable ideology in a time of social and political upheaval, so he’s staking out a more “activist” position to sell himself.

This time, I guess it’s that conspiracies to destroy your opponents might actually be a good thing because they represent action over inaction (he more or less says as much about two thirds of the way through the interview). That seems a weird quasi-fascistic stance (Marinetti and other proto-fascists argued in favor of the same bias towards any action, regardless of its morality), but not one that’s out of fashion in our era.

Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by dingbat on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:09PM (#17049557)
Holiday as a "public intellectual"? he's always struck me as a marketer, retweeter of self-help quotes, and curator of other people's ideas, at best. something about him tells me there's nothing there.
Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by knuththetruth on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:16PM (#17049607)
>he's always struck me as a marketer, retweeter of self-help quotes, and curator of other people's ideas, at best. something about him tells me there's nothing there.

Yeah, sorry. In America, to me, public intellectuals are synonymous with all of that. I guess that’s less true elsewhere in the world. But it’s probably too generous to even given him that label and plays into how he’s trying to market himself.

Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by walkingolof on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:11PM (#17049573)
He is a marketer first and foremost, his Daily stoic book / platform shows that, but there is nothing wrong with that.

If you (as a stoic) want more substance I can recommend Massimo Pigliucci's "How to be a stoic" site (and book) instead.

https://howtobeastoic.wordpress.com/

Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by strong_silent_t on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:28PM (#17049211)
Ok, I doubt I'll ever take an hour to listen to this, but I really enjoyed the book. It was very interesting to see the little particularities of the legal system and the participants that had a big impact. I basically read it straight through in one shot as the host said he did as well. I found the writing to be florid at times (there was a seamless segue between an anecdote of Julius Caesar crossing the Rubicon and Hulk Hogan's decision to sue against the distribution of the hidden camera sextape that made me actually laugh out loud) but I found the asides were unobtrusive enough that it didn't affect the reading.
Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by ordak on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:36PM (#17050257)
Bruh, Russ Roberts makes the hour worth it even if the subject itself doesn't.

Check out any of the econtalk episodes with Nassim Taleb or the ones with Cesar Hidalgo or Pedro Domingos.

EDIT: Hidalgo episode: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2015/10/cesar_hidalgo_o.htm...

Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by knuththetruth on Friday May 11, 2018 @05:42PM (#17050979)
Yeah, in the interview with Holiday, he muses whether it might be good for a handful of billionaires to conspire to destroy public education in America, including planting stories about the evils of schools and teachers in the press[0]. Seems like a real stand-up guy...

[0] 40:52 for anyone interested. I’m not exaggerating, this is pretty much verbatim.

http://files.libertyfund.org/econtalk/y2018/Holidayconspirac...

Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by kbenson on Friday May 11, 2018 @08:21PM (#17051666)
> Yeah, in the interview with Holiday, he muses whether it might be good for a handful of billionaires to conspire to destroy public education in America, including planting stories about the evils of schools and teachers in the press

Yes, he proposes a thought experiment, and them points out how it sounds interesting from an ends getting something accomplished point of view, but also specifically says he recognizes that if he were on the other side he might find it a lot more suspect, and questions (as in actually questions) whether this approach, which is the whole thing being discusses, as it's what Thiel did, is something we should support or not.

So yes, a pretty stand up guy that's willing to note that even if something works for an outcome that he supports the method about which it's achieved might be suspect and we should examine it much closer before supporting it wholeheartedly. What more do you want?

Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by knuththetruth on Friday May 11, 2018 @08:46PM (#17051797)
He tosses in a couple of asides about how if you were on the receiving end of this atrocious idea, you might not like it so much, but your characterization is far too generous for something radically awful that he’s floating as a “thought experiment.”

And of course it’s not just a “thought experiment,” it’s something that right-wingers are doing across the country to aggregately awful and racist results (go look up the track record of Betsy DeVos’ charter school empire). It’s the same kind of dubious “just asking questions” nonsense these guys pull all the time.

Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by kbenson on Friday May 11, 2018 @08:54PM (#17051836)
> but your characterization is far too generous for something radically awful that he’s floating as a “thought experiment.”

He's floating it as a thought experiment to bring up the question of whether a tactic like this, for whatever goal, should be considered good or bad, given that it relies on secrecy. His thoughts are that government should get out of education. He's not actually saying he thinks peopls should go about it this way, he's raising the question of should we be okay with a tactic like this? The extremity of the argument is to make you think critically about it.

The entire conversation is couched in this context. I'm not sure why you refuse to consider it in this one exchange.

> And of course it’s not just a “thought experiment,”...

So you think the person that's calling it out as possibly something people should be wary of or at least examine very closely because of all the possible unintended consequences (which is a point they both spend quite some time elaborating on) is the person that should be viewed negatively? It's not just that something was said, it's how it was said, why it was said, and the larger context. To me it feels like you're missing that.

Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by knuththetruth on Friday May 11, 2018 @09:38PM (#17052006)
I’m not missing anything. He says specifically that he’s “often wondered” about this specific idea, goes into detail about how, if it were to happen, it should be enacted by the wealthy in secret to prevent any opposition, and proceeds to reveal himself favorable to a whole host of other fundamentally anti-democratic ideas (as well as not really push back against Holiday doing more of the same).

Yes, these kind of people are exactly the kind of people one should be wary of.

Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by lamarpye on Friday May 11, 2018 @04:58PM (#17050750)
Or Mike Munger
Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by mathattack on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:05PM (#17048973)
It’s much more deep and interesting than the tawdry title suggests.
Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by mCOLlSVIxp6c on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:51PM (#17049404)
Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by nrook on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:32PM (#17049245)
Gawker always said it was in the business of publishing true stories. Here is one last true story: You live in a country where a billionaire can put a publication out of business. A billionaire can pick off an individual writer and leave that person penniless and without legal protection.

If you want to write stories that might anger a billionaire, you need to work for another billionaire yourself, or for a billion-dollar corporation. The law will not protect you. There is no freedom in this world but power and money.

- Tom Scocca, "Gawker Was Murdered by Gaslight"

Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by dfxm12 on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:04PM (#17049516)
There's so much at play here, that boiling this situation to a generalization like this is outright deception.

* Gawker ignored a court order to take down a post

* Gawker's legal defense had a poor strategy of attacking Hogan's character

* Gawker either didn't coach their witnesses, or they just ignored any coaching:

* You have the author of the post saying he didn't consider any of the reasons Gawker's legal team said made the sex tape newsworthy

* In a trial by jury, the author also said he'd only hold back a sex tape if the subject was under four years old

Yeah, the lawsuit was bankrolled by a billionaire, but it would have been a slam dunk for any lawyer. The fact that they sought $100 Million but were awarded $140 Million by a jury should be telling about how poorly Gawker handled this situation.

Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by trendia on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:04PM (#17049514)
One could also say that if someone puts a video of you having sex without consent, then companies like Gawker will ignore you unless you're a billionaire.

They published a video of a young lady having sex in a bar bathroom, and despite both the lady and her father pleading with Nick Denton to remove the video, he only said "These things pass". The family could not sure, and the outcome was unsure, and Gawker has insurance against these things, so Gawker felt they could get away with it as long as they got the pageviews.

Should you need to be a billionaire to have a non-newsworthy video of you removed?

Re:Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial by s73v3r_ on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:14PM (#17050073)
"You live in a country where a billionaire can put a publication out of business."

I highly doubt Thiel would have been able to do that had it not been for Gawker's general being shitty. Outing Thiel was shitty, publishing the sex tape of a private individual was shitty, and saying that they would publish kiddie porn if they felt it was "newsworthy" was shitty.

Gawker was able to be taken out due to their own actions.