News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by monocasa on Thursday May 10, 2018 @09:01PM (#17044227)
Why not? The signaling layer DHT probably shouldn't be on the phone clients, but everything else should be fine.
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by dmitriid on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:38AM (#17045180)
Because data plans and batteries run out too quickly. And the quality of the networks is really bad compared to non-mobile networks
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by monocasa on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:52AM (#17045223)
Right, so like I said, don't run the signalling DHT on the phones, but run it on everything else.
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by dmitriid on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:57AM (#17045234)
For peer-to-peer to work you need to reroute data/traffic through nodes as well. You you can't really do that on mobile devices because once again: data, battery, network reliability.

If you don't do that and connect directly to a central node, you've done what Skype has done: become a client-server application with centralised servers.

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by monocasa on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:30AM (#17045341)
I'm saying make the nodes heterogeneous, and classify them into "actively participates in the primary functions of the distributed network", and "simply receives pushes that are related to me".
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by dmitriid on Friday May 11, 2018 @04:06AM (#17045678)
What you're saying is: make all mobile nodes clients to centralised servers ;)

As a result, it's much easier to maintain a single architecture than two different architectures with rapidly diminishing number of desktop nodes taking all the traffic.

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by monocasa on Friday May 11, 2018 @10:05AM (#17047364)
...no. It's totally fine to have a decentralized network with a subset of the nodes doing more work depending on what their users want. TOR works like that, PopcornTime did that, etc. Hell, the original Skype network did that to. Gnutella was pretty asymmetric as well.

> rapidly diminishing number of desktop nodes

Do you have any data on that? Or are you counting laptops here as mobile for some reason?

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by dmitriid on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:01PM (#17049988)
"depending on what users want"

What a nice techy answer. Users want an audii-video application that didn't suck their data plans dry by sharing their network bandwidth with other participants in the peer-to-peer network.

The moment you stop sharing your bandwidth and CPU you become a client-server application.

> Do you have any data on that

Any source you pick. And no, it doesn't include laptops. Just an example: https://searchengineland.com/report-57-percent-traffic-now-s...

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by monocasa on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:31PM (#17050217)
> The moment you stop sharing your bandwidth and CPU you become a client-server application.

Even if there's no fixed server you're talking to? You seem to have this weird idea that you can't have a heterogenous peer to peer application.

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by dmitriid on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:49PM (#17050344)
1. When a client does not share its bandwidth its stops being a part of a peer-to-peer network. It becomes a part of a client-server set up.

2. The fact that the server is not fixed doesn't make it a peer-to-peer system. Example: when you watch a video on Youtube, the video isn't streamed from a fixed server. This doesn't make Youtube or whatever client you use to watch it peer-to-peer.

3. Where do these "no fixed servers" come from? Do they magically appear out of nowhere? No. They are some servers that people set up as servers, so this means that:

3.1. If Skype were to retain its peer-to-peer architecture, it would rely on Skype users to be knowledgeable enough to set up their servers (and to turn off peer-to-peer capability in the event of poor machines and unreliable networks).

3.2. The servers by necessity would have to be on desktop computers. Even in 2011 it was apparent that the desktop traffic was rapidly declining, as more and more people were switching to/using mobile. It means Skype would have to route more and more traffic through fewer and fewer nodes. Oh, and yes, those nodes would also see their data plans drain (as not everyone in the world is on unlimited plans). Or — surprise! — set up its own servers, which it did.

3.3. On top of that Skype was en route to ditching peer-to-peer even before MS acquisition, as peer-to-peer architecture had been the primary cause of at least two major (unpredictable and uncontrollable) outages that could easily be avoided with a centralised setup.

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by monocasa on Friday May 11, 2018 @04:59PM (#17050761)
You're aware that in the original Skype peer to peer network, there already existed supernodes that performed most of the heavy lifting that you could opt out of being promoted to, right?
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by dmitriid on Saturday May 12, 2018 @03:24AM (#17052923)
Honestly, it's like talking to a wall.

Original Skype network existed in a world where mobile wasn't a thing.

Original Skype network went down twice exactly because of its architecture.

Original Skype network was already on its way out for the reasons I described several times above.

But sure, keep on believing that peer-to-peer can work in a mobile-first world.