That’s why the law isn’t against driving drunk or impaired it’s a law against driving with alcohol in your blood.
Decision making is more difficult to judge of course, but reaction time is massively important. So if we have a quantifiable measurement, who cares about vague things like drunkenness?
Though, if something like decision making goes south far before reaction time does, then I could totally see an argument being made against using BAC as a measurement. Yet, I don't believe that's the case.
It's often a law against doing either one, but if you are above they legal BAC limit that's much easier to prove beyond a reasonable doubt than is impairment due to alcohol.
So maybe you mean that the law shouldn't be based on BAC?
At one "rolling a stop sign" stop, the cop basically admitted I hadn't rolled the sign, they just wanted to make sure I hadn't been drinking - "Yeah, I just wanted to make sure you hadn't been drinking, have a good night."
edit: subjective, not objective :\
> Any person who drives any vehicle in such a manner as to indicate either a wilful or a wanton disregard for the safety of persons or property is guilty of reckless driving. Reckless driving shall be considered a greater offense than careless driving.
> Every person convicted of reckless driving shall be punished upon a first conviction by a fine of not less than Five Dollars ($ 5.00) nor more than One Hundred Dollars ($ 100.00), and on a second or subsequent conviction he may be punished by imprisonment for not more than ten (10) days or by a fine of not exceeding Five Hundred Dollars ($ 500.00), or by both.
The way it's defined does seem a bit subjective. I'm sure this can be addressed, but at least in this example, it's not immediately clear to me how it can be improved. I would probably get some ideas by looking at other states. The penalties, however, could absolutely be increased. In comparison, the punishment for a first offense DUI [2]:
> (a) First offense DUI.
> (i) Upon conviction of any person for the first offense of violating subsection (1) of this section where chemical tests under Section 63-11-5 were given, or where chemical test results are not available, the person shall be fined not less than Two Hundred Fifty Dollars ($ 250.00) nor more than One Thousand Dollars ($ 1,000.00), or imprisoned for not more than forty-eight (48) hours in jail, or both; the court shall order the person to attend and complete an alcohol safety education program as provided in Section 63-11-32 within six (6) months of sentencing. The court may substitute attendance at a victim impact panel instead of forty-eight (48) hours in jail.
> (ii) Suspension of commercial driving privileges is governed by Section 63-1-216.
> (iii) A qualifying first offense may be nonadjudicated by the court under subsection (14) of this section. The holder of a commercial driver's license or a commercial learning permit at the time of the offense is ineligible for nonadjudication.
> (iv) Eligibility for an interlock-restricted license is governed by Section 63-11-31 and suspension of regular driving privileges is governed by Section 63-11-23.
The penalties are much more, though the end result of the illegal act itself are the same. The only difference is that you drank a couple beers instead of taking your prescription medications. I picked Mississippi simply because I live here currently, but it's similar with all the states I've looked at.
[1] https://law.justia.com/codes/mississippi/2013/title-63/chapt... [2] https://law.justia.com/codes/mississippi/2017/title-63/chapt...
There are too many things that could be considered reckless and even more things that could be extenuating. The penalty for reckless driving could certainly be higher, though, since it's defined as willful or wanton disregard.
The DUI law you cited already covers prescription drugs, by the way. "Is under the influence of any other substance that has impaired the person's ability to operate a motor vehicle;"
You are correct in that the DUI law covers prescription drugs. I hadn't noticed that until you pointed it out. It's rare though, from what I see, for a DUI case to be about anything other than BAC. I have no actual statistics on that.
I guess in my earlier comment the prescription drug part can be replaced by using a cell phone.
That's because BAC is easy to measure. If you want to prosecute for BAC, you just need trusted test results. If you want to prosecute for impaired driving in general, you need to prove actual impairment, which is tough. This is why MADD campaigned for the .08 limit nationwide. It's easy to enforce.
Point is the pretext for the stop is nonsense...
But short of an actual objective test, arresting people for driving after consuming alcohol is plenty reasonable to me.
It is, it's just not a precise one. (Yes, it's an indirect proxy measure, but so are all measures on some levem.)