News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anarchists in the Spanish Civil War (2002) by coldtea on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @05:22AM (#17028458)
>his glowing praise of the Republican Militias is, despite his couching, incredibly biased

As opposed to what, lauding Franco?

Re:Anarchists in the Spanish Civil War (2002) by pfortuny on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @08:55AM (#17029397)
No: as opposed to just being clear, not supportive of any party.
Re:Anarchists in the Spanish Civil War (2002) by coldtea on Thursday May 10, 2018 @04:11AM (#17037139)
Well, if one party is fascists, one can be a little dismissive, and still be perfectly objective.

Objectiveness is not treating each party equally -- it's calling a spade a spade!

Re:Anarchists in the Spanish Civil War (2002) by golergka on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @09:13AM (#17029504)
The fact that you oppose something bad doesn't automatically make you good. For example, despite fighting a war against Nazi Germany, USSR still was an undoubtedly evil tyrannical regime.
Re:Anarchists in the Spanish Civil War (2002) by coldtea on Thursday May 10, 2018 @04:23AM (#17037178)
>USSR still was an undoubtedly evil tyrannical regime.

Well, not much more than what western empires have been for their colonial subjects (who, in addition to slavery, forced labor, mass killings, political rule, torture and so on, they also considered inferior beings). So there's that. Of course another being wrong doesn't make one right -- but at least helps put things in perspective and reduce one-sided smugness.

The difference is that the USSR did so upon its own subjects (which is probably better for the rest of world -- if you weren't their subject).

USSR had a dictatorship of upper echelons of the party, which degenerated into full scale war against large parts of its own population (including ...the upper echelons of the party).

But there are some subtleties too: it's not like people weren't supportive of the regime, especially early on. (Of course Germans were also supportive of the Nazi regime, so there's that).

So, in a sense, they got what they wanted -- it just happened to turn to tyranny. That said, they also had many positive changes from the tsarism on its early days. And they also become a less tyrannical state after Stalin.

Re:Anarchists in the Spanish Civil War (2002) by cies on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @06:24AM (#17028740)
Yups. A real impartial read would just describe the events without favoring any party. A bit like those Nazi documentaries that repeat on Discovery Channel at night in my region. They describe the horrors without any value judgment.
Re:Anarchists in the Spanish Civil War (2002) by aninhumer on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @07:24AM (#17028984)
There is no such thing as a "real impartial read".

Any communication of information will inevitably be limited, and the way that limitation manifests will be influenced by the subjectivity of the person communicating.

The documentaries may present the facts they choose to include in a more dispassionate style than other sources, but this should not be confused with objectivity.

Re:Anarchists in the Spanish Civil War (2002) by cies on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @08:02AM (#17029137)
Sure. But still we talk about impartiality in news. Just give the facts, do not give value judgment (in sharp contrast to Orwell's book).

I never said it is 100% objective, they just clearly avoid siding with any party in those documentaries.

Re:Anarchists in the Spanish Civil War (2002) by Emma_Goldman on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @08:49AM (#17029363)
Right, but the criteria used to choose the facts, what the facts are, and how and by who they are to be communicated, are not value-neutral choices.
Re:Anarchists in the Spanish Civil War (2002) by hutzlibu on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @08:30AM (#17029283)
He did simply described what he saw and experienced. And he liked the spirit in the militia and so he wrote about it. And since he did not join the fascists, he could not and did not wrote, how the experience was for them.

Not more. And all the ugly things he saw, stealing, dirt, unprofessionalism, etc. he states very clearly.