Re:Fake news was illegal in 17th century colonial Massachusetts
by GW150914 on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @04:40PM
(#17024820)
This is a reversed appeal to authority, and the fact that you keep attacking “credentials” rather than anything solid is telling. As Vkou said, they cite their sources. I’ll take that over vague hand-waving around credentials any day. Like people who dismiss Wikipedia, the issue is that you need a case-by-case basis to dismiss cited works.
Re:Fake news was illegal in 17th century colonial Massachusetts
by drzaiusapelord on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @04:44PM
(#17024863)
Again, you're doing everything but addressing the claims.
Again, if I was to link to WashPo or NYTimes, you'd dismiss them as well.
Again, you're just covering for the liars of the world.
[dead]
Re:Fake news was illegal in 17th century colonial Massachusetts
by Chriky on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @04:41AM
(#17028277)
They weren't appealing to authority though. An appeal to authority is "It's true because Snopes says so", they just linked to Snopes' reasoning as a shorthand for repeating the reasoning themselves.
If Snopes didn't provide their reasoning, it would be an appeal to authority.
If you really want to play the "HN says the names of logical fallacies" game, then I'll do you one better and say that challenging me to refute every single line item is an appeal to authority and we should just trust them because everyone says we should. There's no reason to believe them any more than there's a reason to believe much of anything published on somebody's personal website.
[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/kalevleetaru/2016/12/22/the-dai...