There is a good argument that the government should ensure adequate water supplies in the event of disaater. But if the government fails to do that, banning private businesses from “gouging” people by selling water at market rates feels good but actually hurts people. Targeting bail bondsmen in a world where the government abuses minority and low income communities by requiring excessive bail is likewise misguided.
Is exactly what lobbying to get rid of bail bonds is, but not what Google is doing.
Perhaps you meant “money bail”, not just “bail bonds”. But they are doing exactly that. Refusing to take money generated by that system and crediting people working to eliminate the system for that, directing media attention to the issue and established reform advocates, is a way of doing that.
> banning private businesses from “gouging” people by selling water at market rates feels good but actually hurts people
Yes, which is why it would be bad if Google, as you suggest, lobbied against bail bonds. But no one is banning bail bondsmen from selling their product, Google just isn't taking paid ads from the industry.
Your argument undermines itself. When the government fails to act, private parties may act in their own best interest. Private interests may be moral, not purely economical. Pushing Google to sell ads at a discount (compared to the cost of building a reputable website) is as bad as pushing a water dealer to cut their prices.
And finally, it's cold comfort to the thousands (millions?) of abused people for a rich elite to tell everyone else that they should merely lobby and wait until the government deigns to lift the yoke, instead of taking direct action to help.
The case made for that is distinctly underwhelming.
> Bail bonds are a legal service.
That doesn't mean Google needs to carry ads for them.
> Indeed, they are a necessary service for the legal system to function.
No, they aren't. They are a necessary service for the abusive system of excessive cash bail to function, but the entire system of cash bail is facing widespread (and not along traditional party lines) criticism as being incompatible with the fundamental values of our legal system.
But even if this description was accurate, that doesn't mean Google carrying advertising for the industry is necessary.
> Whatever the cause, preventing advertising doesn’t reduce the need to pay bail it simply makes it harder to find a lender.
No, it doesn't, as doing a Google Search for “bail bonds <city>” and comparing the advertising results, map results, and organic web search results would show.
> Restrictions on advertising in the bail industry, as elsewhere, are also likely to reduce competition and raise prices.
The source cited for the argument for the general effect here studied effect of advertising taxes, which increase the price for equal visibility; whether the Google ban is in any way comparable really depends what the main mechanism is for people finding bail bonds through Google-placed ads. If it's mostly search advertisement on relevant terms, banning the ads gives organic results the same effect that paid ads use to have, and reduces the cost of visibility, which would have the exact opposite effect of an advertising tax. This would, therefore, be expected to increase competition and lower prices.