News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why vertical farms are a crock. by hugh3 on Friday September 17, 2010 @01:21PM (#1701942)
While George Monbiot is often wrong about a lot of things, it's nice to see him being right in comparison to someone even wronger than he is.

A quick calculation: the total floor area of the Empire State Building is 63 acres. You can do your own calculations for the cost of building the Empire State Building vs the cost of buying 63 acres of land (which, incidentally, gets light) in upstate New York, but I'm pretty sure that one is much, much, much larger than the other.

Re:Why vertical farms are a crock. by jameskilton on Friday September 17, 2010 @01:28PM (#1701983)
And with that number in mind, you also see another problem with vertical farms: pure space availability. Modern farms are hundreds and even thousands of acres to grow enough food to feed the masses we have today. You would need > 100 of these buildings (ignoring all the other issues for now) to be able to replace one major farm.

Frankly hydrogen vehicles are more feasible than this, but only barely.

Re:Why vertical farms are a crock. by alabut on Friday September 17, 2010 @01:31PM (#1702004)
"You would need > 100 of these buildings (ignoring all the other issues for now) to be able to replace one major farm."

So what if it didn't replace one major farm and just a small local one? And what if the vertical farm and office building idea were combined, so that you had alternating floors of greenhouses for plants and office workers that ate them?

I'm surprised I haven't seen the ideas brought together before, it seems more pragmatic than a dedicated building just for the farm and there's a growing movement to eat healthier at work. We order from FarmFresh at my offices, which supplies us with fruit and veggies from a local family-owned farm and we've been loving the results.

Re:Why vertical farms are a crock. by hugh3 on Friday September 17, 2010 @02:29PM (#1702223)
And what if the vertical farm and office building idea were combined, so that you had alternating floors of greenhouses for plants and office workers that ate them?

It takes 1-2 acres of farmland to support one person's eating requirements, which is two floors of the Empire State Building. Alternatively, there's 21000 people working in the ESB so that's about 200 people per floor. If you devoted every second floor to agriculture (and magically solved the lighting problem) then each worker could acquire 0.25% of his daily caloric requirements from the floor below... maybe a couple of strawberries?

Oh, and the ESB rents for $38 a square foot, so working out the effective cost of each strawberry is left as an exercise for the reader.

Re:Why vertical farms are a crock. by Andrew_Quentin on Friday September 17, 2010 @09:23PM (#1703413)
two floors of the Empire State Building (two floors)

(two floors) x 200 people = 400 floors

(two floors) x 300,000,000 people = 600,000,000 million

Hmm, the world must be really big, or the floors must be really small. If we double that number to include Europe, indeed, lets increase it slightly as Europe has a bigger population, that is 1.5 billion floors of the Empire State buildings to feed only about 1/6th of the world. That does not sound right to be honest.

Re:Why vertical farms are a crock. by phunel on Saturday September 18, 2010 @07:06AM (#1704057)
Pretty sure the 1-2 acre number is quite relative to diet. Perhaps for heavy cattle grazing, bush meat, etc. but not for a vegetable based diet. For an alternative reference see: http://books.google.com/books?id=hwAHmktpk5IC&pg=PA819&#...
Re:Why vertical farms are a crock. by qq66 on Friday September 17, 2010 @04:06PM (#1702629)
$38/year or per month?
Re:Why vertical farms are a crock. by hugh3 on Friday September 17, 2010 @06:46PM (#1703082)
Per year.

I also looked up the average cost of agricultural land per acre in the US, which comes down to about $1200 per acre, or about 0.3 cents per square foot.

This means that for the cost of buying outright the average agricultural square foot somewhere in the country, you could rent that same square foot in a big-city skyscraper for about 45 minutes.

Re:Why vertical farms are a crock. by protomyth on Friday September 17, 2010 @01:48PM (#1702060)
Alternating floors would be kinda harsh on the environmental systems of a modern building (one problem: humidity). The other problem is economic. The builder will make more money on more office space than farming.

Also, a lot of farmers really don't want to live in skyscraper land.