The problem is that there are a lot of less-than-clueful web hosts out there. And if you're less than clueful, the economic rationale for the upgrade probably looks less compelling to you than the "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" rationale for staying with 5 does. (Not to mention that staying with 5 means you don't have to do anything, and less-than-cluefulness and laziness often hang out together.)
Is the extra 2% of market share worth it? Anyone reasonable would say "nope." Especially when it's handcuffs speed as well as sec.
So then - perhaps - it's about ego and other nonsense?
Put another way, WP has the power and position to lead, yet it chooses to __not__ act in the best interests of its users, hosting companies, and internet users in general. For what, 2% market share points?
It would be a huge help to the overall PHP ecosystem if WordPress started required PHP 7, as this would cut the knot and give those slow-moving Web hosts a reason to upgrade. But requiring PHP 7 would be a much smaller help to WordPress itself, as there's nothing in PHP 7 that WP really needs to do what it does, and dropping PHP 5 support would mean creating a non-trivial number of people for whom WordPress no longer "just works." (As the article notes, PHP 5.2 users only account for around 4% of the overall PHP audience, but the overall PHP audience is huge and 4% of "huge" still equals "a lot.")
So to a degree, asking WordPress to drop support for PHP 5 is asking them to take one for the team. It would be nice if they would, but I can understand why they wouldn't want to.