In motorway driving you could probably shut your eyes for 10 seconds every 20 seconds and be perfectly fine almost all of the time. Especially at night time, or other quiet times of day.
So that final reliability rates includes any and all things humans do while driving. (Not what they could do, what they actually do.)
In the scenario I mentioned you'd have at best a 50% duty cycle of good driving, but the accident rate would be substantially lower than 50% every 10 seconds.
I've been hammering this concept for a while :) Unimpaired, non distracted humans are actually really good at driving. We're optimized for processing visual inputs and making fuzzy decisions, have high dexterity and coordination, and fear death. All of that is alien to software.
If you're driving by the textbook, then you have two seconds to react to the car in front braking; the assumption being that you take one second to react normally, and get one extra second for safety.
On the other hand, in something like a play street law grants you exactly zero seconds of response time.
The question is now, of course, whether only those <<10 s intervals count as the failure, or your entire approach to driving (e.g. driving while texting).
Which takes us to 10 9s of reliability. Are there any computers with that level of reliability?
> The question is now, of course, whether only those <<10 s intervals count as the failure, or your entire approach to driving (e.g. driving while texting).
I thought about this all day. I feel that from the moment you can no longer avoid to accident (no matter what you do), until it occurs, is the correct timeframe to measure. Not sure what that number is though.
Say you texted, got in a dangerous situation, then corrected. Is that really a failure? It's a risk of course, and enough people doing that will increase the final death tally. But for each individual driver it's not a failure, if it's not a failure then you can not count it.
i.e. doing it any other way would be counting it twice: Once for those situations that actually caused an accident, and again for taking the risk.
Or put another way, taking a risk and winning is not a failure. (Otherwise where do you draw the line on what a risk is?)
From other comments in this thread, the correct number is actually 10 9's, not 7. So using the accident rate instead of fatality takes you to 8 9's.
That's it? Humans have greater than 7 9's reliability when driving. (As measured by fatalities per time of driving, and assuming a fatality takes 5 minutes, and average speed is 30mph.)
If the cause of a fatality is 10 seconds of failure, not 5 minutes, humans have greater than 9 9s of reliability.
Math: 10 seconds / (1.13 / (30 miles/hour / 100 million miles))
Fatality rate is 1.13 per 100 million miles.
Good luck programming a computer to even stay on and not crash with that level of reliability.
There's this belief that humans are horrible at driving, etc, etc. Until you run that math and realize, no, they're not. There's just a lot of driving going on.