News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why we should all be using Windows 95 by wilsonnb on Monday May 07, 2018 @01:11PM (#17014438)
>Windows 10 will be our best enterprise platform ever and will enable our enterprise customers to be more productive than ever before, simplifying management and deployment for IT and working seamlessly with existing enterprise apps.

Quote from the Windows 10 launch that the writer is complaining about

>Our Product Design Process ™ includes multiple stages like benchmarking, UX, UI design, design of the technical architecture and development of the project plan.

>We apply the Software Development best practices and operate with a quality mindset.

Quotes from the website of the company that wrote the article.

It seems hypocritical to complain that the Windows 10 launch was full of dubious statements when you are doing the same thing yourself.

>It had a memorable launch, it was honest regarding its objectives, focused on the user, objective and transparent.

Really? This is your argument for why we should look to Windows 95 for inspiration? Who cares about whether a launch is memorable? I doubt that the launch of Windows 95 is actually memorable for anyone outside of the tech bubble, anyways.

Honesty regarding objectives is a somewhat reasonable complaint but compared to Windows 10 I don't see why someone would say that 95 was more honest about its intentions. They seem to be making this a dig at Facebook but I don't see why Facebook should be compared to an operating system in this respect.

I honestly have no clue what they mean by saying that Windows 95 was objective. Transparent is pretty much the same as "honest regarding it's objectives". Focused on the user is a good thing but they haven't made a case that today's products aren't focused on the user.

https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*Zt8F-ZqANVVbq4T5VU...

This chart seems to be saying that computers today have less utility than a computer from 1995 running Windows 95. I don't think I even need to describe why that notion is ridiculous.

For those of you that came to the comments without reading the article, don't bother. It's just a poor attempt at marketing by some UI design company.

Re:Why we should all be using Windows 95 by monkeynotes on Monday May 07, 2018 @01:50PM (#17014784)
Hypocrisy on the side of author is a logically false argument about the actual content.

I can be a murdering psychopath and express in my memoirs from prison that while I love killin', murder is immoral. Murder is still widely accepted as being immoral regardless of who asserts the opinion.

That aside I found the article's author heavily corralled observations to support his opinion.

> I’m not trying to compare operating systems with social media or mobile applications,

Yes, yes you are.

> I’m not saying we should solve every UI and UX issue with a start menu

I find it hard to actually understand what the author is really saying, perhaps he/she is saying nothing at all. The irony about substance and honesty isn't lost on me.

Re:Why we should all be using Windows 95 by wilsonnb on Monday May 07, 2018 @02:03PM (#17014903)
I agree that hypocrisy doesn't refute their argument but it does demonstrate that the author themselves either doesn't believe what they're writing or they have some other unknown reason for being hypocritical.

Seeing as no other reason was expressed in the article, I am comfortable taking the hypocrisy as a sign that the they don't believe what they're writing. In my experience, this usually means they are trying to sell me something.

Re:Why we should all be using Windows 95 by monkeynotes on Monday May 07, 2018 @02:10PM (#17014963)
Sorta feel the same way since the article really has zero substance. I hate being cynical but the days of Win95 transparency are truly over.
Re:Why we should all be using Windows 95 by wilsonnb on Monday May 07, 2018 @02:17PM (#17015030)
They're not all the way dead yet. Sublime text seems to be very transparent, in a 90's software sense. Pay some money, get some software, keep it forever. I'm sure there are other examples out there too. It does seem unlikely that any software like that will be as widespread as Windows 95 was, though.
Re:Why we should all be using Windows 95 by sandrobfc on Monday May 07, 2018 @01:25PM (#17014570)
I won't comment on everything, because we all are entitled to have an opinion, but I don't think you took the time to read all the way through the article. Maybe you find it a waste of time, maybe you were simply not interested, and that's ok in either case.

Anyway, I wasn't comparing computers and operating systems from 1995 to what we have today, regarding anything else than a few characteristics like objectivity and transparency.

We never had so much concerning technology and it's impossible to compare whatever was done a few decades ago with what we have now. However, regarding the mindset that surrounds a product launch, I think that we are moving in the wrong direction for some time now.

Imagine if the chart that you've posted here concerned video games, for instance. Wouldn't you agree it makes sense? The same applies to applications, to smartphones, web services... etc.

I don't think it's absurd, but you're allowed to think differently.

Re:Why we should all be using Windows 95 by wilsonnb on Monday May 07, 2018 @01:46PM (#17014759)
I did read the entire article. Most of it more than once as I went looking for quotes to include in my comment.

I get that you weren't trying to say that we should switch from a modern OS to one from the 90's. You make that clear. However, you absolutely spent most of the article comparing Windows 95 to modern day software.

>Take the launch of Microsoft’s latest version of their operating system, Windows 10, for instance. No music, no comedians, no party, no fun and a lot of dubious statements.

>I’m not saying we should solve every UI and UX issue with a start menu, but most web designs out there could surely learn a lot from how Windows 95 solved so many problems by thinking about how target users would deal with their product.

>All 19MBs of Windows 95 consisted on useful tools that you could expect from a computer. There was no Cry Translator or Electric Shaver app — wonders of the modern day, available on any smartphone — as it was focused on a few objectives only.

>Imagine if such a strange object as a phone that could only make calls existed. That would be the equivalent of Windows 95 on a computer back then. It had everything you ever needed from it, without the unnecessary waste of space.

>What really stands out are the main qualities that Windows 95, as a product, had and that are not common nowadays. It had a memorable launch, it was honest regarding its objectives, focused on the user, objective and transparent.

The problem I have with the chart is not that is shows junk and paid increasing - it's that it shows the utility decreasing. As a percentage of the junk/paid/utility trifecta, I might agree that utility's percentage is going down over time but the absolute quantity of utility has increased an insane amount in the last 23 years. Your chart does not show that, at least not very clearly.

This quote is what precedes the graph:

>Imagine if such a strange object as a phone that could only make calls existed. That would be the equivalent of Windows 95 on a computer back then. It had everything you ever needed from it, without the unnecessary waste of space.

Phones like that do exist. You can get one for your house still. If you're willing to accept texting as a feature, you can get a cell phone like this. You seem to be arguing that such a device is somehow superior to an iPhone or my Pixel because it doesn't have the "unnecessary waste of space". You completely gloss over the fact that the utility section of the 2015 graph should have things like a web browser, Google or Apple Pay, Uber, Slack, Netflix, Spotify, GrubHub, and many others in it which make it substantially bigger than the 1995 graph.

Re:Why we should all be using Windows 95 by sandrobfc on Monday May 07, 2018 @01:57PM (#17014860)
Concerning the phones, I do know and I do own still a phone like that, I was just being sarcastic.

I believe that the "free" utility is decreasing, leaving space for some junk no one really uses (any smartphone comes with dozens of functionalities that we'll never use but are paying for) and paid features. These last features add utility, but for some reason, they are not included originally.

When I bought my first computer, with Windows 98, it came with Microsoft Office, Photoshop and a few other "free" tools. I've paid for the computer and those additional features were already there. It's added value that you now have to pay for and that's not only Microsoft's responsibility (at least, concerning Photoshop).

The same way you have to pay for several of the apps you've listed, such as Uber, Netflix, some Google services, Spotify premium... I don't recall the existence of "premium features" for what I used in 1995, but Spotify is the perfect example of what I illustrated in the graph.

The free version adds some utility, the paid version increases its utility and there's some junk in between that no one really listens to.

Re:Why we should all be using Windows 95 by wilsonnb on Monday May 07, 2018 @02:11PM (#17014980)
I kind of agree with you on this, but I don't think Spotify is a good example. It's not like the 1995 equivalent of Spotify was free unless you were pirating all of your music. Uber and Netflix are similar in that they replace taxis and cable TV respectively.

Anyways, if you can, I'd suggest putting another paragraph above or below the graph in the article explaining what you've said in this comment. I did not get this point from reading the article and I think a lot of other people will also struggle with it.

Re:Why we should all be using Windows 95 by sandrobfc on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @06:04AM (#17019901)
Well, I don't think there's a good equivalent of Spotify in the 90s, people just bought or downloaded what they wanted to hear. My point is that now we have this "free" software that, sure, you can download for free, but you'll need to pay if you want to use all its features.

I will provide an additional explanation in the text to clarify this part. Thanks for your feedback!