News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California to become first U.S. state mandating solar on ... by downandout on Monday May 07, 2018 @12:08AM (#17010329)
You're correct that I should not have used the word residents in my quick interpretation of that study. However the study I linked to is directly relevant to the comment I replied that I replied to, which was about too many transplants arriving. Too many transplants are in fact not arriving, because as this study indicates, 1 million more people left than arrived from other states.

in fact, California gained, not lost, 3 million people between 2007 and 2016.

Most of those gains were through births to existing residents, which says nothing about California being a destination for transplants, which was the point that I was refuting. Children born in California generally don't have a choice as to whether or not to live there. Adults do, and on a net basis, they are choosing to leave.

Re:California to become first U.S. state mandating solar on ... by dragonwriter on Monday May 07, 2018 @12:48AM (#17010465)
> Too many transplants are in fact not arriving, because as this study indicates, 1 million more people left than arrived from other states.

“From other states” alone, sure, OTOH, California has had net positive total (domestic and international) migration.

Re:California to become first U.S. state mandating solar on ... by downandout on Monday May 07, 2018 @12:49AM (#17010468)
If you include illegal immigration, sure. I'm not sure that's a positive for existing residents though.
Re:California to become first U.S. state mandating solar on ... by dragonwriter on Monday May 07, 2018 @01:13AM (#17010540)
Wasn't the concern upthread thst you were trying to argue against that the level of inbound migration was too high?
Re:California to become first U.S. state mandating solar on ... by downandout on Monday May 07, 2018 @01:27AM (#17010578)
The full original sentence I replied to was this:

“Some people think we're getting too many transplants and that regulating the development of new housing will somewhat curb that”

The “transplants” he is concerned with are those with both the means and legal standing to purchase and drive up demand for new homes. How many illegal immigrants to California fall into that category? So most of the “transplants” that are relevant to this discussion are coming from other US states.

Re:California to become first U.S. state mandating solar on ... by dragonwriter on Monday May 07, 2018 @02:52AM (#17010813)
> How many illegal immigrants to California fall into that category? So most of the “transplants” that are relevant to this discussion are coming from other US states.

Why in this thread do you keep making the mistake of thinking migration consists only of domestic migration and illegal immigration? You know that legal international migration (both immigration directed at permanent residency and more transient legal residency by foreigners) is a thing, right, and actually quite a big one in Californiaz right?

Re:California to become first U.S. state mandating solar on ... by daveFNbuck on Monday May 07, 2018 @02:34AM (#17010758)
People can immigrate legally from other countries. Most of the people I know in the San Francisco bay area who own a home are Chinese immigrants.
Re:California to become first U.S. state mandating solar on ... by downandout on Monday May 07, 2018 @02:52AM (#17010819)
Are you honestly arguing that the majority of international immigration to California consists of wealthy Chinese?
Re:California to become first U.S. state mandating solar on ... by dragonwriter on Monday May 07, 2018 @03:24AM (#17010933)
Well, when it comes to demand for property owenrship, you don't actually have to be resident; wealthy Chinese do a lot of that without ever living in the place where they are driving up prices.

But certainly a sizable share of the foreigners migrating into California have substantial means (either pre-migration assets and/or post-pubescent income) and China isn't exactly underrepresented among the sources of such migration.

Re:California to become first U.S. state mandating solar on ... by downandout on Monday May 07, 2018 @03:48AM (#17011033)
So now you’re actually arguing that the vast majority of international immigration to California is not poor people from Mexico, but rather wealthy Chinese buying up homes?

Any data to back up this claim or are you just arguing to argue at this point? There are many news outlets that would love to see your data on this, because it is a startling revelation indeed.

Edit: to those downvoting this, please provide data corroborating his claim above. Otherwise there is nothing to downvote, as I am simply calling into question his claim that wealthy, legal Chinese immigrants outnumber poor illegal immigrants from Mexico in California.

Re:California to become first U.S. state mandating solar on ... by dragonwriter on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:29AM (#17012524)
> So now you’re actually arguing that the vast majority of international immigration to California is not poor people from Mexico, but rather wealthy Chinese buying up homes?

No, and you can tell they because the only mentioned of the phrase “wealthy Chinese” in my comment refers to people buying up property from abroad, and the phrase.“vadt majority” (or even the word “majority”) doesn't appear in my comment at all.

> Any data to back up this claim

Since I never made the argument you reference, and it's not necessary either to the core issue or the tangent from the main discussion in my comment, why would you ask for that?

Re:California to become first U.S. state mandating solar on ... by apta on Monday May 07, 2018 @04:09AM (#17011106)
> Most of the people I know in the San Francisco bay area who own a home are Chinese immigrants.

He's saying that the majority of immigrants who are buy houses are Chinese. I'm not arguing for or against that by the way. For places where this already took place, Toronto and Victoria Canada.

Re:California to become first U.S. state mandating solar on ... by dragonwriter on Monday May 07, 2018 @09:31AM (#17012530)
> He's saying that the majority of immigrants who are buy houses are Chinese

No, I'm not saying anything like that.

Re:California to become first U.S. state mandating solar on ... by downandout on Monday May 07, 2018 @04:19AM (#17011136)
Yeah but he keeps jumping around to either side of the issue just to argue. Either way, I’m done with it. He can argue with himself now. There’s a reason he has 50,000 karma points - he has lots of time and patience with which to argue.
Re:California to become first U.S. state mandating solar on ... by Steel_Phoenix on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @10:56AM (#17021307)
They don't need to purchase homes to drive up demand. If they are living in homes then they are driving down supply.