News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by haZard_OS on Sunday May 06, 2018 @11:16AM (#17006696)
I read Magee's book Confessions of a Philosopher some years ago and it was agonizing. Magee's personal bitterness was so pungent and so awkwardly colored his thoughts on philosophical topics that I found myself struggling to finish the book.

Of all the books on philosophy I have read, that book by Magee was easily the most off-putting.

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by iorrus on Sunday May 06, 2018 @01:09PM (#17007164)
I thought it was a fantastic introduction to Western Philosophy.

One of the top 5 books I recommend to people who have an interest in philosophy but no academic background in the area.

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by copperx on Sunday May 06, 2018 @01:55PM (#17007398)
What are the other 4?
Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by iorrus on Sunday May 06, 2018 @04:42PM (#17008406)
This is an extremely personal question. I have extreme biases, I personally favour:

Bryan Magee's book on Schopenhauer.

German Idealism/The Fate of reason by Fredrick Beiser.

Hegel and the Hermetic Tradition by Glenn Magee

Kant's Transcendental Idealism: An Interpretation and Defense by Allison

Plato: Complete Works by John Cooper is good

The Paidea series by Jaeger is amazing as is the four volume collection by Giovanni Reale if you're interested in ancient philosophies (like me)

-----------

The 'phenomenological' school is considered important.

Making Sense of Heidegger by Sheehan

Merleau-Ponty's Philosophy by Hass

However I think most true Western thought is to be found in the great works of literature. Ovid/Dante etc. try reading Howard Blooms work "The Western Canon".

Personally I find most western philosophy quite turgid.

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by adjkant on Sunday May 06, 2018 @05:32PM (#17008685)
At the Existentialist Cafe by Bakewell I think is the best catch-all for phenomenology in many ways despite being part historical rather than full philosophy. Would highly recommend even if one is familiar with the usual suspects featured in it.
Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by woodandsteel on Sunday May 06, 2018 @08:20PM (#17009502)
Agreed, it's a wonderful book.
Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by woodandsteel on Sunday May 06, 2018 @08:19PM (#17009498)
The Dream of Reason by Anthony Gottlieb is a good introduction to Greek philosophy. You really should start there, since everything since then is a response to what they had to say.
Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by ehudla on Sunday May 06, 2018 @04:18PM (#17008273)
His book /Men of Ideas/ is a set of conversations with leading philosophers (among them Searle, Chomsky, Quine), accessible to non experts. I read it as a kid and whenever I happen to revisit it I find just as inspiring. It seems to be out of print, though the videos from the BBC show are ironically on youtube,

/The Great Philosophers/ in which prominent philosophers discuss the major figures in the canon of Western philosophy (Plato, Aristotle, Hume, Kant, etc.) is also enticing, though less than /Men of Ideas/.

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by intralizee on Sunday May 06, 2018 @09:48AM (#17006398)
I think he would find the philosophy on eternal reoccurrence and determinism helpful. I’m somewhat an atheist and find the two calming around existence & death. I wonder how so by his imagination of Einstein was rooted on his work or the ideology that god doesn’t roll dice.
Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by solipsism on Sunday May 06, 2018 @10:36AM (#17006555)
You think a person who steeped himself in philosophy his entire life is unfamiliar with eternal recurrence (not "reoccurrence") and determinism?

No. Such people are bound to die restless and unfulfilled. There's a class of people who need to know the answers to all questions. It strikes me as a sort of ADD (I mean it in the non-technical "I am not a shrink" way). I agree with the article that the answers to many questions are unattainable or unknowable.

The trick as an atheist is to find peace with that. Some even satisfy their natural drive toward spiritualism with it.

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by Koshkin on Sunday May 06, 2018 @11:00AM (#17006631)
Indeed - philosophy is similar to theology in that both have unattainable goals: Philosophers look for answers to questions for which there are no answers; theology studies that which does not exist.
Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by tlb on Sunday May 06, 2018 @01:12PM (#17007181)
Theology also studies how stories about things that don't exist affect people's thinking and beliefs. That part is grounded, interesting, and relevant.

Having an unattainable goal is not a bad thing!

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by Satam on Sunday May 06, 2018 @01:23PM (#17007251)
I'm often left a bit baffled and frustrated when atheists start off their arguments with coherent and interesting thoughts only to end, what could've been the start of a productive discussion, with snarky and childish remarks.

I, for one, dabble in these questions out of genuine and innate curiosity and I believe others do too. Isn't it then counterproductive to deal in absolutes when the only thing we can be certain of is that we are still quite too ignorant to answer those ultimate questions?

Maybe I am reading too much into your "theology studies that which does not exist", but, again, remarks like these are really off-putting. It is already almost impossible to find discussions in this area that take an exploratory and open-minded approach, and I'd hope that at least forums like these could be free of that.

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by solipsism on Sunday May 06, 2018 @07:04PM (#17009150)
Sounds like you're expecting everyone to see eye to eye with you. The person you're responding to expressed how he or she sees things. The only person who seems to be trying to cut off certain lines of conversation is you.
Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by Satam on Sunday May 06, 2018 @10:26PM (#17009977)
I don't think you're being fair here. Although it is possible that the person did not write the comment in the disingenuous way in which I perceived it, I am not willing to regard him as so naive.

Importantly, it is not the opinion itself which I find off-putting - it's the way in which it is conveyed. It was neither insightful nor did it encourage any meaningful discussion... No, I'd go further: consciously or unconsciously its only purpose was to reaffirm the author's pre-existing convictions and to put down those of others.

I also understand why my comment could come off as trying to cut off certain lines of conversation as well, but the only reason why I am even getting frustrated about this is because I want to have MORE of those honest conversations about these seemingly controversial topics; it doesn't matter to me which way they lead me.

I believe that the "ultimate" questions have value in them that is not necessarily tied to them being answered, at the very least in the same way the exercise is good for one's body - I hope you would agree here as well. Unfortunately, most of the time, it is quite hard to find balanced online discussions which would bring an exploratory and open mindset to these questions; instead, they're usually quickly bombarded with dogmatic responses - an example of which I'm now ranting about.

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by boomboomsubban on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:40AM (#17012238)
Theology is generally the study of the dogma of your chosen religion. Assuming any of the field is based on truth requires you to already believe what the religion says, as "a long time ago this guy said this" is not a convincing argument. Almost everyone will find this true, as even if they believe it for their chosen religious theology they generally don't for all the others.

The "ultimate questions" are the realm of philosophy.

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by Satam on Monday May 07, 2018 @10:49AM (#17013142)
Although there is no question that a large part of the religious dogma is straight out false, it seems to me that, knowing how many things we still have no understanding of, it would be just as unproductive to outright dismiss all of it as false.

But, again, my issue is not with the dismissal - I'm completely fine with the idea that people might come to that conclusion and I'm open to the idea myself. My issue is with the cheap jabs that are not even honest expressions of one's feelings.

My criticisms might seem strange and uncalled-for if one only considers this instance in isolation, but it keeps happening, again and again, and throughout many different types of media. Just recently I was reading Sam Harris' book; it's quite small and a fun read at times, yet it quickly became a chore to get through, as it is full of those irrelevant cheap-shots. The thing is, in the right place, in the right context, those remarks could be interesting, however, when misplaced like that, they end up coming off as someone simply having a chip on their shoulder.

I consider it really unfortunate that it seems that the atheist side, whose thoughts I'm most interested in hearing, fallbacks to this strategy quite too often. And thus, instead of a philosophical debate, we end up with a two-person monologue where the beliefs of the atheist are presented no more rationally the those of the religious.

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by boomboomsubban on Monday May 07, 2018 @01:24PM (#17014564)
>Although there is no question that a large part of the religious dogma is straight out false, it seems to me that, knowing how many things we still have no understanding of, it would be just as unproductive to outright dismiss all of it as false.

You either dismiss it all as false, accept it all as true, or you are a hypocrite. The evidence is the same for all theologies. It's unproductive to consider ideas that either have no evidence or have no logical basis, and that describes theology.

> The thing is, in the right place, in the right context, those remarks could be interesting, however, when misplaced like that, they end up coming off as someone simply having a chip on their shoulder

For most of the past several thousand years, politely wording these sentiments could end in your death. Even now, a failure to at least pay lip service to Christian theology leaves you largely ineligible for public office, and may limit other opportunities. So yes, there is a chip on their shoulder, many people have a negative opinion about them no matter how tactful they are.

>And thus, instead of a philosophical debate, we end up with a two-person monologue where the beliefs of the atheist are presented no more rationally the those of the religious.

There is no debate with "the religious," there belief is based on things that are not debatable. They often pride themselves on how their belief comes from faith. The philosophical debate is another thing altogether.

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by Satam on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:02PM (#17017571)
Organized religion is a human endeavor and it should be taken as such. However, if we put aside the politics and consider it strictly from the view of someone who is trying to figure out the world, I don't see why it is necessary to throw out the baby with its bathwater.

The fact that many different religions try to tackle the same questions makes the possibility that a particular one has THE answers seem unlikely. However, the fact they all gravitate towards the same kinds of answers is something that should not be easily dismissed if we want to move the discussion forward. To me, it seems that some sort of spiritual element is always gonna have to be in play; that is, if we want to have any chance of answering those questions in a manner that is not only true in the scientific sense but also in a way that satisfies the restlessness which had inspired the search of the answers in the first place. I must add, that the need to satisfy the restlessness, of course, should not be taken as an excuse for accepting sub-par resolutions.

>For most of the past several thousand years, politely wording these sentiments could end in your death. Even now, a failure to at least pay lip service to Christian theology leaves you largely ineligible for public office, and may limit other opportunities. So yes, there is a chip on their shoulder, many people have a negative opinion about them no matter how tactful they are.

This has genuinely changed my view on this matter, thank you for bringing it up. Reading or listening to eloquent people discuss the topics, it's been easy for me to get hypnotized by their elegant arguments (even the ones I don't agree with) and to forget the human that has crafted them. Growing up in a country where militant religious attitudes (or strong religious attitudes at all, really) are basically non-existent, I didn't really think about the point that those people might have actually been slighted by religion in some way.

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by boomboomsubban on Monday May 07, 2018 @10:09PM (#17018286)
>However, the fact they all gravitate towards the same kinds of answers is something that should not be easily dismissed if we want to move the discussion forward.

If you analyze their answers, you realize that the same questions remain after answered. Answering "why are we here" with "god made us" just changes the question to "why is god here?" Their answers are similar as they generally were not developed independently.

And again, all of their answers have no logical or scientific foundation. I could not develop Christian theology without already having a bible, while the philosophical debates presumably could be reproduced independently.

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by intralizee on Sunday May 06, 2018 @10:45AM (#17006576)
No I didn't mean to create the impression he is unfamiliar with the two. The two are calming around existence & death for me because it makes me not strike an ADD as you put it. Also creating an natural drive towards spiritualism as you put it again. It's sort of funny you thought I wrote the comment assuming he never studied the two.
Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by solipsism on Sunday May 06, 2018 @11:37AM (#17006777)
I think he would find the philosophy on eternal reoccurrence and determinism helpful.

This structure very clearly implies that he is unfamiliar with the two. Just as "I think you would like Brazil" implies the person has never been there.

No big deal. I only mention it because "It's funny you thought" implies you don't realize your wording made this interpretation the obvious one.

creating an natural drive

I didn't put it that way. The natural drive is preexisting. That's sort of what the "natural" means.

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by intralizee on Sunday May 06, 2018 @11:59AM (#17006852)
I agree with you and blame my lack of sleep. Learned something from you about what it means to refer to natural as well. :)
Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by BadThink6655321 on Sunday May 06, 2018 @10:58AM (#17006617)
I disagree. He wants to know, as much as is possible, what is true. He isn’t interested in a philosophical placebo.
Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by intralizee on Sunday May 06, 2018 @11:27AM (#17006738)
Well it depends on what he believes truly benefits himself in the end. I guess a person can refer to anything as a placebo if used to change oneself.
Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by alexashka on Sunday May 06, 2018 @02:06PM (#17007471)
> He’s an agnostic troubled continuously by the unknowability, indeed the incomprehensibility, of total reality; of what lies beyond the world of appearances and can never be breached.

The article gave me the impression that Bryan Magee is troubled by boredom mostly.

These 'meaning of life' questions can trick people into believing that it's not knowing the answers to some questions, that is the cause of their unrest.

It's never that, it's always so much more simple :) I don't know that philosophy students realize they're playing mind games with themselves, for self-amusement. They have a tendency to take ideas seriously, life seriously, and then oh my, you have 1001 problems to deal with!

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by qntty on Sunday May 06, 2018 @10:14PM (#17009930)
If someone finds some feature of human existence troubling, what does it mean to say that it's 'not really' that feature that's causing them trouble? Sure, he might be happier if he was more stimulated, but that doesn't mean that he wouldn't still be a bit troubled when he took a little time to remember what troubled him before.
Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by woodandsteel on Monday May 07, 2018 @07:26PM (#17017335)
As someone with a background in both philosophy and psychology, I can't help thinking that both Magee's sense of terror and his ambition to make an immortal contribution to philosophy both come at least in part from his mother's failure to love him as a child.
Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by blueprint on Sunday May 06, 2018 @11:51AM (#17006825)
His questions are easy. He just never learned from someone who knows the answers. If I were in his shoes I would have asked a master about them.

> Why is the universe so incredibly complicated?

It's not. What exactly is the range of the term universe? It's broad so he ought to point out what he wants to know exactly and where it is. Things of the world are simple when you know, but they are complicated to find out .

> does it [(time)] have a beginning?

Yes, it begins with activities. Not a very deep question; it needs improvement to see a meaningful answer. If you have the wrong question in your mind then even a master's answers will not match.

> the riddle of why we sleep

This is more of a biology question but if you want to know from a theory standpoint why it happens, the answer is that what exists does so by repeating what has been in itself and it only changes based on what happens to it. Living beings repeat the bonds of birth and death repeatedly. Death is a time of rest for human beings because their life is a time of work.

> What the hell is it all about?

Imprecise question. Clear why he obtained no concrete answer.

> What are we doing here?

Trying to improve your truths through the precious opportunity of life

> What’s going on?

You will know that after you can open your eye to the fundamental principle of the world. But he didn't have enough virtue to reach that level yet.

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by sctb on Sunday May 06, 2018 @01:22PM (#17007246)
We're missing out on what you have to share because you're addressing questions asked not by Magee but by a journalist constructing a narrative for the readers of this article, and so we get this dismissive comment. We don't need such dramatized attacks on “wrongness”—we need thoughtful discussion where we stand to learn something substantive. Hacker News readers can handle it.
Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by blueprint on Sunday May 06, 2018 @01:32PM (#17007288)
It seems you're getting a little caught up in an assumption that I posited who "he" is. It's not important... what's important are the questions themselves. For example, if you truly intended to gain what I have then you should either (a) prove that there is no such dire wrongness or (b) provisionally retract your claim that the result of such wrong thought is not actually huge. I'm not commenting to be treated well by humans. If you can't show something which you need to know which we can exchange in real conversation, then I'm going to remain wary of the actual meaning of your reply.
Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by SmooL on Sunday May 06, 2018 @01:47PM (#17007358)
How does one find a master to ask such questions?

I'd also be curious as to what your thoughts on the fundamental principle of the world is?

Re:Philosopher Bryan Magee remains wonder-struck by the ulti... by blueprint on Sunday May 06, 2018 @01:58PM (#17007413)
If you want to find a real master of the world then you should confirm how few people were among the true greater philosophers in our history. But that will be very hard for you without a guide because the ones who were alive in the past have already had their records changed past the point of usefulness to humans. Aside from that, use a search engine to see if one has appeared recently. What search term do you need to find such a being?

The principle of the world is that what happens is made by 'what is' in problems. People don't realize why things happen to them until a long time passes because they are not so conscious of the causes they carry in own consciousnesses. That's why Socrates said to know thyself. Then you will be able to see. However, how do you really get to know yourself? The answer is to know life. Like I said, every living thing does something repeatedly on the basis of what is in its origin of life. You can change results in your life for the better by changing to better problems.