News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Confirmed: Intel says HDCP 'master key' crack is real by barrkel on Friday September 17, 2010 @12:22AM (#1700122)
Is it economically threatening? Really? I have my doubts about that.

As I understand it, the hardware manufacturers were peddling a fantasy to rightsholders that their hardware could protect their content from end to end. By getting rightsholders to buy into this fantasy, these hardware manufacturers got a whole lot more leverage, licensing revenue, new (i.e. forced) hardware sales, etc.

But I'm not sure it did a whole lot for the rightsholders other than try and assuage their fears of the digital dawn, a kind of snake oil, as it were. I don't think people who actually want to view content without paying for it even noticed. The people who did notice were consumers who were inconvenienced by the incompatibilities created by coordination problems being made unnecessarily difficult etc.

If anyone is the loser here, I would think it's a handful of big-brand hardware manufacturers and patent / license holders, trying to e.g. exclude cheap no-name Chinese manufacturers from competition.

Re:Confirmed: Intel says HDCP 'master key' crack is real by tlb on Friday September 17, 2010 @01:27AM (#1700249)
I think it's simpler than that. The labels would only support a standard with DRM, but secure DRM is impossible, and making copying inconvenient won't keep the content off torrents. It must have sucked to be on that standards body.
Re:Confirmed: Intel says HDCP 'master key' crack is real by Hoff on Friday September 17, 2010 @11:13AM (#1701410)
It's a compromise between what the rights-holders want for security (eg: usually more), and what the hardware vendors can reasonably implement and profit from (eg: usually less), and the degree of hassles and adverts that the end users will tolerate (some), and the trade-offs between the ease of use of any cracks with the fear of and the threat of and the costs of legal entanglements, and the cost of entry for folks outside the consortium (usually licenses and patents).

Everybody involved - content, device, user - is looking to maximize their profit and minimize their costs.

Hardware guys: No content, no buyers, uh-oh, no device sales.

Content guys: No devices, no market, uh-oh, no media sales.

Customers: No fun, uh-oh, no device and no media sales.

It's one of them marketing min-max messes, in other words.