Re:7-Zip: From Uninitialized Memory to Remote Code Execution
by pfg on Thursday May 03, 2018 @10:44AM
(#16986466)
> To be fair to virus scanner vendors, the only way to mitigate this kind of bug is NIH: don't use 3rd party libs, implement everything yourself. But then, of course, without bugs yourself, as well :)
That is not the only way to mitigate such vulnerabilities. AV vendors have had plenty of time to work on sandboxing parts of their scan engines that have repeatedly been found to have vulnerabilities like this one. Somehow we've arrived at a point where no one would recommend using a browser that doesn't utilize sandboxing to some degree, but when it comes to security products, you can count yourself lucky if they don't just run that code as SYSTEM. That should really tell you all you need to know about the state of the AV industry.
Re:7-Zip: From Uninitialized Memory to Remote Code Execution
by RaleyField on Thursday May 03, 2018 @01:10PM
(#16987753)
> no one
Plenty of people recommend Firefox despite it sharing processes between tabs. More than 10 years after MS sandboxed IE.
Re:7-Zip: From Uninitialized Memory to Remote Code Execution
by infogulch on Thursday May 03, 2018 @10:36AM
(#16986387)
> the only way to mitigate this kind of bug is NIH
Or, you know, conduct audits of open source libraries they use and contribute fixes back.
Re:7-Zip: From Uninitialized Memory to Remote Code Execution
by jessaustin on Thursday May 03, 2018 @10:56AM
(#16986583)
It is a very blurry line between running strange code and running library code against strange data. Mostly though, I'm trying to say that AV boxes should be outside the firewall.
To be fair to virus scanner vendors, the only way to mitigate this kind of bug is NIH: don't use 3rd party libs, implement everything yourself. But then, of course, without bugs yourself, as well :)