News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by icebraining on Thursday May 03, 2018 @06:28AM (#16984685)
If you instead want a cryptographically-verified immutable append-only log, there are lots of non-blockchain structures for immutable append-only logs that permit only a finite set of writers

Yes. I actually like the concept of Bitcoin, but it's very annoying how so many of its fans seem to think Satoshi Nakamoto invented Merkle trees.

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by geofft on Thursday May 03, 2018 @06:56AM (#16984790)
I'm actually okay with using "blockchain" to mean "distributed Merkle tree" if that's what people want. Just be clear about what properties you want so nobody builds mining into your system when unnecessary.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by ericb on Thursday May 03, 2018 @07:19AM (#16984932)
Hold up. That's really reductive. It isn't just a merkle tree. It's a merkle tree that you can look at and say "this merkle tree would cost 2 billion dollars to forge." This is valuable because if someone hands you one, you can tell if you're looking at a fake.
Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by icebraining on Thursday May 03, 2018 @07:30AM (#16984990)
I didn't say Bitcoin is just a Merkle tree. My point is that Bitcoin is a system that combines different pre-existing components - like Merkle trees and Proof-of-Work - in a novel way, but people then split that system, and call those components "blockchain". Some user here in HN actually wrote "Git is a blockchain".

But the best example is that nonsense of "permissioned blockchains".

Re:Goldman Sachs to Open a Bitcoin Trading Operation by geofft on Thursday May 03, 2018 @01:45PM (#16988064)
icebraining's claim is that Satoshi did invent something, but the thing he invented was not Merkle trees.

If you have an application where forging or forking the tree isn't meaningful (e.g., any possible Certificate Transparency Merkle tree can be merged at any point into any other one), then the thing that Satoshi invented is not useful to you, and having it cost $2 billion to build such a Merkle tree is a waste.