Re:India tells UK to turn off the aid tap
by _b8r0 on Thursday September 16, 2010 @04:42AM
(#1697235)
The way UK aid works is terrible. On the one hand we're told there's no money in the treasury, yet on the other we're handing out money to countries with faster growing economies, space programs and a questionable need.
I'm glad India at least had the gumption to stand up and tell us where to shove our aid, that £3.3 billion is much better in our pockets.
Re:India tells UK to turn off the aid tap
by dazzawazza on Thursday September 16, 2010 @06:35AM
(#1697408)
The foreign office, treasury and overseas development ministries have been hinting for 6 months or so it was going to go.
Given the mess we've helped create/worsen in Afghanistan and the destabilising effect that has had on the already shaky Pakistan a retargeting of aid did make sense. It benefits India as well as a more stable Afghanistan/Pakistan will lower their security/military costs.
The recent delegation to India spoke of swapping aid for trade, something both countries need. They need our luxury goods (whiskey) and high tech engineering (satellites) and we need cheap manufactured plastic crap and indian students to go to our universities.
Re:India tells UK to turn off the aid tap
by InclinedPlane on Thursday September 16, 2010 @04:27AM
(#1697208)
Japan's foreign aid to India is mostly in the form of loans, so it's unsurprising that there could be a year where the repayments outweighed new loans.
Re:India tells UK to turn off the aid tap
by Kliment on Thursday September 16, 2010 @04:47AM
(#1697249)
Oh, that makes sense. I never thought about loans. Is this a common arrangement? I had this image of aid being counted as money given away, not loaned.
Re:India tells UK to turn off the aid tap
by electromagnetic on Thursday September 16, 2010 @06:34AM
(#1697407)
These loan 'aid' is very common, although thankfully is becoming (too slowly) less common. This is what landed many 3rd world countries in major problems in that the money given didn't stimulate their economy (for reasons we won't go into) enough to cover repayments.
India on the other hand has a fast growing economy, which means it can more easily afford the loan payments. So for a country like India these 'loan aids' are likely much less harmful than for a country like Sudan.
Re:India tells UK to turn off the aid tap
by taitems on Thursday September 16, 2010 @03:49AM
(#1697130)
I wonder what the relation is between this story and the upcoming Dehli Commonwealth Games. I'm sure there's an element of "putting up a front", in a similar way to China spray painting their grass green and building walls around their poor for the Olympics.
Re:India tells UK to turn off the aid tap
by arethuza on Thursday September 16, 2010 @05:36AM
(#1697329)
Did BR actually build many railways? I thought they mostly closed existing ones that had been built by private companies in the 19th and early 20th centuries.
Re:India tells UK to turn off the aid tap
by dazzawazza on Thursday September 16, 2010 @06:28AM
(#1697400)
1948 BR was formed from the Big Four [1] but they themselves were formed from the merging of many smaller operators over the preceding 50 years or so (if I remember correctly)
TBH BR performed reasonably well given investment until they were sold off into the private sector where productivity of staff and reliability slowly started to decline. This was matched be an increase in use so it's hard to see if the sell off caused the problems.
In the 1970's BR designed and prototyped a high speed leaning train but government funding was withdrawn because of fears that 'britain can't manufacture anymore'. The start of the end IMHO.
I'm glad India at least had the gumption to stand up and tell us where to shove our aid, that £3.3 billion is much better in our pockets.
Given the mess we've helped create/worsen in Afghanistan and the destabilising effect that has had on the already shaky Pakistan a retargeting of aid did make sense. It benefits India as well as a more stable Afghanistan/Pakistan will lower their security/military costs.
The recent delegation to India spoke of swapping aid for trade, something both countries need. They need our luxury goods (whiskey) and high tech engineering (satellites) and we need cheap manufactured plastic crap and indian students to go to our universities.
India on the other hand has a fast growing economy, which means it can more easily afford the loan payments. So for a country like India these 'loan aids' are likely much less harmful than for a country like Sudan.
TBH BR performed reasonably well given investment until they were sold off into the private sector where productivity of staff and reliability slowly started to decline. This was matched be an increase in use so it's hard to see if the sell off caused the problems.
In the 1970's BR designed and prototyped a high speed leaning train but government funding was withdrawn because of fears that 'britain can't manufacture anymore'. The start of the end IMHO.
[1] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Four_British_railway_compan...