I do believe that the thing that would change the housing stock situation for SF is to remove sales taxes and add land value taxes. Just that change alone will make workers and renters richer overnight, and would change the anti-development mindset of owners quite a bit, considering that low-dense units will pay the highest amount.
"A tax upon ground-rents would not raise the rents of houses. It would fall altogether upon the owner of the ground-rent, who acts always as a monopolist, and exacts the greatest rent which can be got for the use of his ground."
- Adam Smith, Wealth of Nations
"It is in vain in a Country whose great Fund is Land, to hope to lay the publick charge of the Government on any thing else; there at last it will terminate. The Merchant (do what you can) will not bear it, the Labourer cannot, and therefore the Landholder must: And whether he were best do it, by laying it directly, where it will at last settle, or by letting it come to him by the sinking of his Rents, which when they are once fallen every one knows are not easily raised again, let him consider."
- John Locke, "Some Considerations of the Consequences of the Lowering of Interest and the Raising the Value of Money"
It's known that land tax together with similar antimonopoly taxes can't be shifted. What's nice is that not only this type of tax doesn't slow down the market, but on the contrary makes it more effective. Essentially without rent capture (antimonopoly tax) there is an open sink in the economy, so no matter how hard people work, all this value exits out of the economy, mostly in form of parked money in real estate.
As George predicted, all technological progress will just yield higher real estate prices and everybody will be working even harder than before.
I agree a land tax would push the owners of vacant lots to develop them. But, the NIBMY owners of single family homes will still fight against the building of new apartment complexes and try to constrain housing supply (to prop up their property values). I certainly would hope that more apartments would be built though!
https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2018-03-14/californi...
We know that artificially restricting the supply of housing increases prices.
https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-10-24/faster-gr...
Knowing why is important, though, and the law of rent explains the mechanics.
I'm in agreement with the idea that more building should occur. I'm just cautioning that even if someone destroyed every housing regulation in existence, or even if lots of public housing were built, we shouldn't be surprised if rents remain super high.
In the technology space we're used to seeing costs plummet from year to year. A land title system, by contrast, will predictably see increasing prices over time, while simultaneously extracting a flow of rent.
Why is this? It ultimately comes back to the Law of Rent. The amount that landlords are able to charge directly corresponds to the produce obtainable at that location over their next best alternative... and that alternative is likewise set that way up until you reach the "margin" which is the best available rent-free location.
Since all land has been homesteaded, there's not much of a ceiling on rents... they tend towards the entire nominal productivity of the site. And the more desirable that site is, the more astronomical the rent.
We want locations to be desirable, so in effect we actually do want rent to be high. It's just important that everyone share in that rising wealth. In other words, we need to create a high demand for labor, by shifting taxes from labor onto idle landlords. Land speculators are like patent trolls atop the surface of the planet.