News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California Supreme Court Transforms the Test for Who Is a... by thaumasiotes on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @04:44AM (#16965439)
> If you can't provide your main business without this set of people, then those people are probably your employees?

This doesn't make any sense. Farmers are not employees of grocery stores. Factory foremen are not employees of drop shippers. Amazon warehouse staff are also not employees of drop shippers. Comcast cable layers are not employees of YouTube.

You think farmers aren't employees of grocery stores because the stores could buy the same food from different farmers? That's just as true of the IT company and its contract developers.

Re:California Supreme Court Transforms the Test for Who Is a... by rtpg on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @05:04AM (#16965505)
This is a pretty big simplification. Grocers buy produce from the farmers, not their time.

This matches some conrractors, of course. But it also extremely doesn't match many contractor developers.

Are you required to be online 4-6 hours a day? Do some of the companies employees not even know if you are actually a contractor? Are you the one picking up the metaphorical phone when the company's client is calling with a support issue? You might actually be an employee

If you show up with a deliverable , can go on vacation without clearing it with anyone, and are actually your own boss... Well that's different of course

Re:California Supreme Court Transforms the Test for Who Is a... by CamperBob2 on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @08:22PM (#16973031)
If you show up with a deliverable , can go on vacation without clearing it with anyone, and are actually your own boss... Well that's different of course

It was different, but my point is that the 'B' clause ("Service is outside the business' normal variety", whatever that means) can be interpreted to remove this distinction.

A lot of people are cheering for this bullshit without thinking it all the way through.

Re:California Supreme Court Transforms the Test for Who Is a... by lstroud on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @08:22AM (#16966388)
There’s also a pretty big difference between a Corp to Corp relationship and a 1099.
Re:California Supreme Court Transforms the Test for Who Is a... by semi-extrinsic on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @04:58AM (#16965480)
But that is wildly different. A farmer provides goods that hold value for almost anyone. Once they have produced a bushel of apples, that bushel can be bought by anyone. On the contrary, once a software developer has produced some code, it only holds value for the specific company that order this specific piece of code.
Re:California Supreme Court Transforms the Test for Who Is a... by dgacmu on Tuesday May 01, 2018 @09:18AM (#16966778)
Not always. Consider two scenarios: (1) adding a feature to an existing product that the company sells. (example: writing a better grammar checker for MS word). (2) contracting with the developer of a small open source embedded database to add a specific SQL feature that you wanted to use in your web backend.