Re:Stripe Atlas for LLCs
by toomuchtodo on Monday April 30, 2018 @09:37PM
(#16964007)
What was the motivation for 10 year vesting vs the more widely used 1 year cliff/4 year vest out?
We're a consulting firm. We looked back at Matasano and thought about how value was added over the life of the firm, and 4 years didn't nearly capture it. If we do product stuff, we'll just spin that out into a separate entity, and that would probably be 4/1.
Re:Stripe Atlas for LLCs
by toomuchtodo on Monday April 30, 2018 @10:09PM
(#16964117)
Makes sense. Appreciate the reply.
The only LLC-specific wrinkle I think we ran into is that we had to spell out that vested equity wasn't equivalent to a pro-rata claim on profits or distributions. But that's like a a sentence or two.
Non-vesting Atlas LLCs are probably super useful for a bunch of different kinds of companies.
But I'll argue that a non-vesting structure is never appropriate for a multi-member startup.
I'm not picking on Atlas; lots of people DIY or even pay lawyers to put this stuff together and get it wrong. We got it wrong at Matasano. It was painful.