Re:Microsoft helped imprison a man for ‘counterfeiting’ soft...
by scandox on Monday April 30, 2018 @08:10AM
(#16957847)
Did he or did he not seek to make a meaningful profit from this activity? I can't see information on that in the article. Also did he use the downloadable file or did he actually burn from an existing DELL disc? I think there would be software differences potentially there right? I got a reinstallation media sent out from DELL and it definitely seemed customised.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Microsoft helped imprison a man for ‘counterfeiting’ soft...
by belltaco on Monday April 30, 2018 @09:40AM
(#16958471)
There are some quotes from his emails here which show he was clearly trying to profit and counterfeit the CDs to make them look exactly like the originals.
https://blogs.microsoft.com/on-the-issues/2018/04/27/the-fac...
Re:Microsoft helped imprison a man for ‘counterfeiting’ soft...
by Karlozkiller on Monday April 30, 2018 @08:44AM
(#16958084)
According to what he says himself in an interview he was selling the CDs 25 cent a piece after paying for production in China and shipping to the US. I don't think you can get much meaningful profit from that.
Re:Microsoft helped imprison a man for ‘counterfeiting’ soft...
by Hamuko on Monday April 30, 2018 @03:29PM
(#16961482)
The 25 cents a piece is total bullshit. His appeal sentencing pretty clearly states how his argument was that the value of damages for each disc was $4, which was the price he was selling them for.
The 25 cents a piece is just some PR bullshit Lundgren is trying to spin in order to come out as the good guy here as he poses in pictures wearing a fedora while he sleeps on a bed made out of counterfeit Dell recovery discs.
Re:Microsoft helped imprison a man for ‘counterfeiting’ soft...
by criddell on Monday April 30, 2018 @09:21AM
(#16958336)
It's been reported that he earned $28,000 from the transaction.
Re:Microsoft helped imprison a man for ‘counterfeiting’ soft...
by Karlozkiller on Monday April 30, 2018 @09:57AM
(#16958583)
Yes, he claims that was all the money he ever got from his 'accomplice' for selling a lot of things over several years, including screws and the CDs in question. The CDs according to him were only a minor part of that sum.
Doesn't mean it's necessarily true, for obvious reasons. And one can only hope the court looked through all that as thoroughly as possible.
Re:Microsoft helped imprison a man for ‘counterfeiting’ soft...
by simion314 on Monday April 30, 2018 @08:24AM
(#16957950)
He cloned a disk, bit by bit, also the cover /label on the disk was cloned. The disks were not cracked so the user had to input the serial number from the bottom of the laptop
Re:Microsoft helped imprison a man for ‘counterfeiting’ soft...
by microwavecamera on Monday April 30, 2018 @08:25AM
(#16957955)
Basically he was making counterfeit restore and Windows installation CDs, which you can just download for free, and distributing them with refurbished PCs he was selling. M$ claimed damages of $25 per CD based on the $25 they charge for their refurbishing program which provides a copy of the install media but also included a new license and participation the M$'s authorized refurbishing program even though no licenses were illegally provided. So now this guy is going to federal prison over what's really a copyright violation.