Yeah, it's extremely easy to not share your data with them.. if you know they don't care about protecting it.. But what about all of the other people on the internet that don't know this guy doesn't care about your privacy?
Convincing businesses to take your personal data seriously is the whole point, and you shouldn't get a free pass just because you only handle people's personal data in your spare time.
Because people voluntarily provide it to them.
> But what about all of the other people on the internet that don't know this guy doesn't care about your privacy?
Governments confront problems with this general shape all the time... the result is usually labeling requirements. Sure, this guy should not be allowed to claim he has a crack team of elite cybersecurity engineers when he doesn't. Regardless, no one is asking him keep secrets for them. It's a niche Craigslist.
>Because it's a small operation?
You're actively campaigning to degrade privacy (and also user freedom, competition, and choice) to a much greater degree by displacing these activities onto large, centralized platforms. Especially those which are monetizing your data to a high enough degree that it's worthwhile to staff a compliance team for the privilege of continuing to do so.
Voluntary or not, there are some rights that you cannot give up to someone else. In Europe, one of those rights is control over your own personal information.
There's also the issue of information symmetry. Just because I voluntarily bought your product doesn't mean that you should be 100% free from any liability that it may cause.
Which is a dangerous illusion. You don't control anything you hand over to someone else.
Even at a bank, if you open a joint account (enable sharing) and the other person absconds with the contents, you’re out of luck.
You do have control, actually. You and the bank have an agreement as such.
This is also where GDPR is at. Without it, in theory, you have a shrinkwrap tl;dr agreeement with the service, but in practice, they can do whatever they want with your data, with no repercussions.
See: Facebook and CA. Facebook misused my data (Because my friends opted in to sharing it), CA misused my data (Because they weren't even supposed to be given access to it), and the outcome? Nothing of consequence.
GDPR does three things:
1. It makes those repercussions have teeth.
2. It makes sure that you give informed consent to use of your data. (Unsurprisingly, similar laws exist for banks!)
3. It clarifies what has to happen when you stop being a user of a service. (Prior to it, de-facto, your data would be opted into whatever changes of the data usage policy the service made - regardless of whether or not you still had an active account, whether you agreed with the ToS, etc. If you deleted your Facebook account, you had zero leverage of how your data would be used.)
If that were true, you would not be able to post this comment (the most highly sensitive category of personal data, political views) in a public forum.
But if it's all the same, would you mind sharing your credit card numbers, SSN, and date of birth? I won't leak it, pinky swear.
The GDPR concerns all information related to people. It doesn't treat PII (i.e. identifiers) separately.
I think your reading of the comment you're replying to is itself obtuse, bordering on malicious. They clearly understood that the core issue with GDPR for the OP is risk, and suggested a reasonable solution to address it:
> The solution is to create a company so that the company can shoulder most of the risk
Further:
> It's extremely straightforward to not share data with a "fly-by-night" website like this.
Not if you're using the site. The €20 million fine OP is worried about is only triggered in case of an actual leak of personal data. If you're seriously worried that you might end up leaking personal data, maybe you shouldn't be storing it to start with?
The author is clear that they are concerned with having to defend themselves in court.
The fine is the bait that draws the true threat.
The fines are imposed by the government; in the UK that means the ICO. They cannot be levied as the result of a lawsuit brought by private parties. The ICO also has discretion when levying fines, and they've stressed repeatedly they will not be reaching for maximum penalties.
GDPR offers the prospect of big fines if you screw up badly enough. It also is likely to lead to a lot of lawsuits. But there are totally separate issues, and cannot be conflated as you are doing.
OP might get sued. And he might get fined for €20 million (although realistically...no, of course not). But he won't get sued for €20 million.
> The fine is the bait that draws the true threat.
That's simply incorrect. You're looking at a normal civil case, with normal damages.
The risk remains.
We started out talking about the risk of an opportunistic civil suit filed by a law firm working on a contingency basis seeking a €2m payout; now that we've established that isn't possible, we're talking about the risk of an actual fine for breaking an actual law levied by an actual regulator (who is on record as saying that large fines would be a weapon of last resort in the most extreme cases).
So other than the risk being much lower, the likely penalties much lower, the chance of an unfair outcome being much lower, and the incentives and mechanisms being completely different...
...sure, the risk remains.
This is an obtuse, bordering on malicious misreading of the post. They're not unwilling to implement the necessary features. They're unwilling to shoulder the risk.
> Personally I think fly-by-night websites should be the last people responsible for handling personal data. If they're unwilling to attempt to comply with regulations, then perhaps the internet is a better place without these sites.
This isn't a data broker, a credit reporting agency, someone with a giant sensor fleet, etc. It's extremely straightforward to not share data with a "fly-by-night" website like this.