In our case, the best decision was to block EU traffic and ban EU users from the forums we operate. GDPR compliance for forums specifically is essentially impossible, because almost all forums allow users to embed external images. The owners of the servers on which those images reside could start deploying tracking cookies that the forum doesn't know about at any moment, and therefore there will likely be exactly 0 GDPR compliant forums, except perhaps text-only forums. That issue alone was enough to get us to block EU users, but that doesn't begin to address any of the other fine points of the law.
You also seem to be uner the impression that the law will not be abused by revenue hungry governments to reach into the pockets of foreign corporations. Call me cynical, but if that doesn't happen, it would be the first time in history. The spirit of GDPR is great. The implementation is the exact opposite of great.
You are not going to get fined by the EU for that happening. The sites issuing the tracking cookies are the ones in breach, not you.
> You also seem to be [under] the impression that the law will not be abused by revenue hungry governments to reach into the pockets of foreign corporations. Call me cynical, but if that doesn't happen, it would be the first time in history. The spirit of GDPR is great. The implementation is the exact opposite of great.
I honestly cannot see that happening in this instance. Most governments bend over backwards to appease big businesses and often at the expense of consumers. What you're suggesting would be a complete U-turn on Western politics.
That's a misinterpretation of the law. We can indeed be held responsible for that - it's no different than putting a pixel on ourselves. The burden is on us to know what we are including on pages under GDPR.
Most of the people in favor of this law, who claim it's not a big deal unless you have bad intentions, haven't neither read it nor spoken to legal experts about it, and are not in charge of having to comply with it themselves. If they were, most would be singing a different tune. I am not arguing that there wasn't a need for some reasonable limits on tracking. But GDPR is an atrocious law designed to allow the governments of EU countries to reach into the pockets of companies in other parts of the world (especially the US). This serves a dual purpose: to make it easier for EU Internet companies to flourish by sucking down the capital of their foreign competitors, and filling government coffers with money they aren't entitled to. That is how this law will be used, regardless of the well-intentioned hopes of those that support it.
IMO, forums that are large enough to be potential GDPR enforcement targets -- which is a vanishingly-small percentage of them -- should be doing their own image rehosting anyway.
Image hotlinking has always been a very perilous thing to allow, from both legal and technical standpoints.
GDPR does not discriminate based on the size of the site. My 7 year old niece could start a site, throw Google Analytics code on there, and be fined millions of dollars for not disclosing it if an EU visitor happens to come by. That is the world we now live in.
This hysteria of yours is nonsensical.
You're pulling out the scariest parts of the GDPR and assuming everyone is going to get bettered with it regardless of:
* whether they've already been warned or not
* their site's size or income
* business size or income
* nor even the severity of the transgression
Thankfully our universe and reality doesn't operate in your worst case fear-mongering. And as I've already stated, you can look back at the history of EU legislation to see evidence to that effect. Posting absurd and unfounded arguments like your previous example really doesn't help the situation one bit.
By the way, there are zero provisions in the law that require warnings before an action is taken to issue fines. You can keep saying that they’ll issue warnings, that doesn’t make it true.
Or to phrase it in our own words: You can keep saying that they'll fine your niece millions for a hobby project but that doesn't make it true.
So... proxy the images and strip the cookies?
Sure you can make it as complex as you want. But the practical upshot is this: as long as you are going around using FUD rather than fact to pretend that the GDPR is unworkable you're setting yourself up for a nasty surprise. Instead go and make a 'best effort' and spend a few productive weeks on getting rid of the most obvious differences between where you are today and where the law says you should be and you will be doing better than most and will be able to sleep just fine because just like with running away from hungry lions you only have to run faster than the competition.
And as long as you're not in fintech, social media, advertising, medtech, insurance or doing something really shady you most likely will be fine anyway because those segments are where the majority of the people that I talk to about this subject expect the first action.
The courts of '28 unique countries' are not each and every one of them going to give a unique interpretation of this law. What you can expect is that starting 2019 or so a couple of serious offenders will be first warned and then fined to show the rest of the world they're not dicking around this time so make-believe arguments won't cut it.
I'm pretty happy that the GDPR exists, the business world had a bowshot in the form of the cookie law, that got ignored or arm-chair legalesed into an ineffective operation when everybody had the option to actually comply with the spirit of the law as well as the letter (the spirit: stop tricking users everywhere: the letter: put up a cookie wall and continue tracking like before once the user inevitably clicks 'ok').
When industries fail to self-regulate sooner or later regulators step in. In this case it is later but as laws come the GDPR is surprisingly clear and accessible.