News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It's time for us to say farewell by matthewmacleod on Sunday April 29, 2018 @06:26PM (#16954254)
even for sites smaller than Wikispaces, GDPR compliance can easily run into the 7 figures

Where on Earth are you getting this number from? It sounds entirely fictional to me.

GDPR compliance for small services is a relatively straightforward process.

Re:It's time for us to say farewell by downandout on Sunday April 29, 2018 @06:28PM (#16954263)
Where on Earth are you getting this number from?

From the consultants I have spoken with and looking at the issue for my own company. Depending on what your service does, the process of GDPR compliance can be incredibly complex and involve rewriting a significant percentage of your code. Even then, you may not be in the clear because it is up for unique interpretations in the courts of 28 distinct countries. It is, quite simply, a mess. Maybe it's one that will work out to users' benefit in the end, but that doesn't help the companies trying to serve them that don't have millions of dollars to spend on compliance.

Re:It's time for us to say farewell by codingdave on Sunday April 29, 2018 @06:32PM (#16954280)
Does it cost 7 figures if you don't hire consultants?
Re:It's time for us to say farewell by downandout on Sunday April 29, 2018 @06:42PM (#16954321)
Depends. If you happen to be both a lawyer that is well versed in the laws of all 28 EU countries, who can divine how each country will interpret and enforce the law, and also a coder with lots of time on your hands to implement in code what you hope is the correct interpretation of these laws, you may be able to do it for free. Most companies don't have a person like this though, and need to rely on outside experts for one or both of these.
Re:It's time for us to say farewell by user5994461 on Sunday April 29, 2018 @06:59PM (#16954380)
The interpretation of laws and specific contexts are usually relatively straightforward for people who are trained in legal speak, not engineers.

There should be hardly any change needed as long as the service only gathers data that is required for it and users are willingly using the service.

The problem if for companies that do heavy identification of users against their will like in adtech or companies that gather and resell personal information.

Re:It's time for us to say farewell by gerdesj on Sunday April 29, 2018 @07:44PM (#16954588)
Bollocks! First off: GDPR will be harmonised across all 28 member states (not countries) - that's the point of it. For example in the UK, the current Data Protection Act of 1998 will be superseded by GDPR (https://www.itgovernance.co.uk/data-protection)

You do not need to be a lawyer to understand GDPR, you merely need the ability to read, and have a few hours to devote to research. Implementing a policy that is compatible with GDPR is not hard. It does require some thought and some time and will need some training across your organisation. If you do not have a market in the EU then it need not worry you at all. Funnily enough, if you bin (or neuter) those social icons and a few .js thingies from your website you'll be well on the way. Now think about how you would like to be treated, personally ... yep - you'll be fine. No lawyers needed and certainly not seven figure sums for handwaving. You really can use research and common sense and some time, to do the job in house effectively.

I might politely suggest that it is a pretty good standard to work to anyway: it is designed to protect the privacy of individual people. I consider myself an individual and perhaps you do too.

Re:It's time for us to say farewell by downandout on Sunday April 29, 2018 @08:02PM (#16954683)
You do not need to be a lawyer to understand GDPR

And yet billions are being spent on exactly that - because it's an incredibly complex law that can indeed be subject to different interpretations in each country. I have been briefed on this point specific by lawyers in the EU for to whom we paid a fortune, only to decide that it was too risky to allow EU traffic.

It's not just a matter of taking away "a few .js thingies" as you put it.

Re:It's time for us to say farewell by gerdesj on Sunday April 29, 2018 @08:35PM (#16954851)
I am a director of a UK based IT company (MD) I am also the ISO9001 senior worrier and an ISO27001 sponsor. Just in case you are concerned that I might be a PHB (I do not have enough hair anyway): I run Arch Linux on all my PCs and am personally CREST accredited.

The purpose of GDPR is protect individual's right to privacy - I doubt you can fault that. You and I are both individuals ...

Have you actually sat down with a copy of the GDPR a clear mind, and some really good coffee and bothered to read it? If you are arguing the toss with me based on something that someone else has told you then go away.

GDPR is designed to protect people - you and I if you like. I'm a fan of it.

Re:It's time for us to say farewell by downandout on Sunday April 29, 2018 @08:43PM (#16954888)
I have read it, as have our lawyers, which is why we have no choice but to block all EU traffic from our services. All fans of the law think it will only be used to go after "bad" guys. But that just isn't how laws like this are used in practice. They are designed to be easy to violate for a reason - that reason being to generate massive revenue from fines.

You should take a look at this well reasoned blog post about why someone stopped selling their products in the EU - https://www.brentozar.com/archive/2017/12/gdpr-stopped-selli...

There are just far more issues here than you're acknowledging.

Re:It's time for us to say farewell by codingdave on Monday April 30, 2018 @10:29AM (#16958793)
All legal questions can be answered with "It Depends." The lack of clarity form the courts is to be expected, but isn't that different than any other legal grey area. And yes, there are concerns. And yes, if a company wants to skip out of the EU and wait for the dust to settle, that is a valid business choice.

But people are arguing with you because you are all over this thread acting like it is the only business choice. Or that we all need to spend millions to make that choice. In truth, it is a risk management decision, not a legal one, because the legal answers are unknowns. You clearly are drawing this into the quadrant of both high likelihood and high consequences... which is fine, for you. But different organizations may have different answers, putting GDPR compliance into a different risk quadrant, and those are their own decisions to make.

Re:It's time for us to say farewell by fiddlerwoaroof on Sunday April 29, 2018 @08:44PM (#16954891)
As someone who has had to try to figure out how to implement GDPR, my takeaway so far is that it might eventually be ok, once the courts have clarified what it actually requires. But, that process will be quite profitable for European governments.
Re:It's time for us to say farewell by mst on Sunday April 29, 2018 @08:40PM (#16954875)
My employer, https://shadow.cat/ is offering GDPR compliance consultancy, and so far the take away has been "if you're a non-tech company, it's not honestly that hard" plus "if you're a tech company, it's only hard if your entire business model is built around exploiting your customers' data".

If it costs 7 figures to hire consultants, either your business model was parasitic in the first place or your consultants are attempting to fleece you.

(if you don't believe me, email [email protected] and ask - I run the tech team, I'm not nearly as much of an expert on the rules as he is - and if you're emailing him to ask with no intention to pay us anything, that's fine, just make sure to blame me)

Re:It's time for us to say farewell by matthewmacleod on Monday April 30, 2018 @12:28AM (#16955739)
I’m sorry, I have a great deal of difficulty believing this.

there are essentially no situations in which GDPR compliance should be particularly onerous. The principles are pretty simple, and while it will take some time until there is clarity on edge cases, most actions required should be straigtforward.

I’d be fascinated to know what product you build that is so inextricably tied to user data that it will cost “millions” to comply.

Re:It's time for us to say farewell by downandout on Monday April 30, 2018 @02:04AM (#16956162)
I’m sorry, I have a great deal of difficulty believing this.

Then you obviously haven’t read the whole thing or had to comply with it.

Re:It's time for us to say farewell by matthewmacleod on Monday April 30, 2018 @02:23AM (#16956233)
I have done both.

It it possible that you’ve been fleeced by your consultants? You’ve notably avoided talking what you’re doing that would require onerous compliance, details of which would go at least part way towards substantiating our rather unbelievable ideas about the cost of compliance.

Re:It's time for us to say farewell by downandout on Monday April 30, 2018 @05:02AM (#16956959)
Ironically, your employer (from your HN profile) loaded a Facebook tracking pixel, Google Analytics, and a multitude of third-party javascript libraries (from which it calls functions such as "clickTrackerInit") when I went to their home page - all without asking for permission. If you helped with their GDPR implementation, perhaps you aren't as familiar with GDPR requirements as you seem to think you are, because those are glaring violations.
Re:It's time for us to say farewell by downandout on Monday April 30, 2018 @03:13AM (#16956442)
Have you done a search to verify that others feel that GDPR compliance is easy and cheap? I think you’re way off base here, and I’m not alone.
Re:It's time for us to say farewell by matthewmacleod on Monday April 30, 2018 @03:22AM (#16956486)
Yeah, anybody I’ve met with experience is pretty confident in that.

The people I’ve met who aren’t fall into three categories:

1. People who don’t know much about the rules and have concocted a distorted version of them

2. People who are running a business that relies on misuse of personal data and who will be directly affected

3. People who have some ideological or politicical viewpoint which generally opposes regulation.

I have encountered no situation where someone has been able to demonstrate to me a convincing case where GDPR compliance is onerous, or indeed more work than any best practices they should have already been following.

Re:It's time for us to say farewell by downandout on Monday April 30, 2018 @03:31AM (#16956530)
I’m beating a dead horse talking to you, but you really should look outside of your own opinion and do some research on the issue one of those days. There is a reason that so many people have issues with this law.