Re:It’s Impossible to Prove Your Laptop Hasn’t Been Hacked
by kazinator on Sunday April 29, 2018 @11:45AM
(#16952471)
"Stores keys on someone's server" cannot be trusted, no matter what the copyright status is of the code running on the server.
Code licensing or copyright status isn't a form of security.
The issue isn't just that the remote server's code is impervious to scrutiny. A locally installed program that you can reverse engineer isn't automatically trustworthy because it is open-source, or even copylefted. Someone actually has to reverse engineer the binary and prove that it matches the source code. Many users of free software trust upstream binaries. (Even if they compile their own programs, they trust compiler binaries at some point.)
Code licensing or copyright status isn't a form of security.
The issue isn't just that the remote server's code is impervious to scrutiny. A locally installed program that you can reverse engineer isn't automatically trustworthy because it is open-source, or even copylefted. Someone actually has to reverse engineer the binary and prove that it matches the source code. Many users of free software trust upstream binaries. (Even if they compile their own programs, they trust compiler binaries at some point.)