I would say getting perspectives from different people is never irrelevant. So no I would not argue against diversity even in those cases you listed.
It is possible you just didn't recognize the cliques. They aren't always super obvious even when they are prevalent.
I like racial minorities in the workplace are a different concern than gender minorities. Mindless discrimination based on race is very much noticed and looked down on these days. I wouldn't say its the same about gender. If all your co-workers always forgot to invite you to lunch or assumed you wouldn't want to do what they do because of your race you would be right to compare.
Re:The Difficulty of Hiring Women
by yummyfajitas on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @03:29PM
(#1695543)
Now you are begging the question. How is a woman's perspective different from a man's perspective on Fourier analysis, scaling a database or technical analysis of stocks?
As for cliques, I don't have much experience with them. Within university departments, I only observed three particular flavors of clique: domain specific (math/physics, number theory), chinese, and women. I suppose you are right - the woman clique did have women from multiple domains in it.
As for being in the minority, I don't agree with you there. In all walks of my daily life, I am an extreme (racial) minority. In the past month or two, excluding family, I've had a conversation with perhaps 2-3 people of the same race as me. It isn't an issue at all - right now, I feel like less of an outsider than during past periods where I dealt with lots of people like me.
[1] Examples would include every field I've ever worked in: trading stocks, medical imaging, quantum physics.