News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by Hnrobert42 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:44AM (#16946866)
I was all set not to believe you, but after I read Eric’s emails, I agree with you. It appears both MS and Eric are overstating their altruism.

Emails: https://blogs.microsoft.com/uploads/prod/sites/5/2018/04/2LU...

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by zeusk on Saturday April 28, 2018 @11:09AM (#16947993)
I don't see how Microsoft is overstating anything.

A) They didn't bring the case, US Customs did.

B) As the victim (financially) of the Crime they were approached to state the financial damage to decide on the restitution amount and they chose to pick the lowest price on market and further reduce that amount to depict their actual profitability for selling obsolete software.

C) Eric's intentions were clearly not to recycle and reduce waste but to profit from this racket of duping buyers into buying "genuine" recovery discs with Microsoft and Dell logos and tampered activation keys (read the court docket for more details).

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by sp332 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @12:57PM (#16948499)
The price they quoted was for a disc with a valid license. His discs didn't have licenses, so they were worth a few cents apiece.
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by zeusk on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:01PM (#16948531)
> His discs didn't have licenses

That is where you're wrong. Read the docket, better yet here is a screenshot from the demonstration that the discs had keys replicated from original Dell recovery discs:

https://imgur.com/3eHjPjO

Moreover, "so they were worth a few cents apiece." - The value of financial damage (especially in this case) matters only towards deciding the restitution amount. They also have a cut-off, above which the crime is considered to be under federal jurisdiction which wouldn't have mattered in this case since the amount was obviously above the cut-off and the crime was of inter-state nature.

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by gonesilent on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:38PM (#16948684)
Looks like to me the normal error using a none oem disk with an oem key that is baked into bio
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by zeusk on Saturday April 28, 2018 @02:19PM (#16948855)
How can a Lenovo laptop have Dell's activation info baked into BIOS?

If the disk had no activation info, setup would have prompted for a key (trial keys for 30 day are available online).

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by oldcynic on Saturday April 28, 2018 @03:56PM (#16949172)
It doesn't, it has Lenovo's SLIC in the BIOS. More than enough to activate Windows. Device manager would no doubt show it's a mess of not installed drivers though.

Big OEMs including Dell and Lenovo use an activation baked into the BIOS and a SLIC (system licence internal code) that's also in the BIOS. No activation required after restore from legitimate or otherwise CD or restore partition. It won't match the code on the machine's sticker, even if it's 100% legit just bought new from maker.

Search will turn up plenty on how SLIC works.

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by zeusk on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:30PM (#16949282)
Lenovo's SLIC wouldn't load an invalid key that required them to then copy the key manually from COA on the laptop itself.
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by dfox on Saturday April 28, 2018 @03:57PM (#16949177)
IIRC when the BIOS contains the activation data blob the discs are not manufacturer specific. There also used to be discs (at least in the windows 2000 times) that only checked for correct manufacturer name in DMI (or something similar), which obviously were manufacturer specific (AFAIK for a long time this is not possible).
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by devindotcom on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:01PM (#16949189)
The Dell-specific stuff would be on the disc. On page 32 you can see the gov operator has to input the Lenovo's COA key to activate the OS:

https://imgur.com/a/Ua7SLWo

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by zeusk on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:41PM (#16949318)
The gov operator would also have to input a key during setup and OOBE if the disk did not have a tampered key/activation mechanism.
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by justrobert on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:11PM (#16948568)
I haven't had to recover from an OEM vendor install in awhile, but if I remember right there are many situations where the user does not need to input the serial number for activation.
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by zeusk on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:18PM (#16948599)
Windows Vista and up support reading device activation information from the system BIOS.

However, in this case you wouldn't see "Contact Dell for Support" on a lenovo laptop as demonstrated during the trial (see screenshot above).

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by justrobert on Saturday April 28, 2018 @02:04PM (#16948797)
The image gallery doesn't tell us if they were using a dell recovery cd or something else.
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by djsumdog on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:03AM (#16947455)
Yea .. seems kinda shady. Still, we see shady practices for people in large companies all the time. They've got an entire team of board members and crew to share in the process, so the result is almost always monetary compensation, fines, etc.

Maybe we should see more CEOs in jail in a similar manner, when their decisions to commit fraud intentionally causes the loss of savings and homes for so many average working class people?

In any case, we're seeing his small shop and his attempt to spin the case. I often feel like I'd never own my own business, because in a lot of cases, you have to make these types of risks and compromises to make it. Just look at the FedEx guy who gambled all his companies money to keep them solvent. Had he failed, he probably would have been prosecuted and jailed, but he made it, so he's praised for taking an insane risk at the cost of everyone he employed.