Re:Is it time to lower America's drinking age?
by jrockway on Monday April 21, 2008 @07:44PM
(#170082)
> We democratically have fixed the age at 21 (for most states).
Well... sort of. The federal government stopped giving highway money to states that didn't follow its demands to raise the drinking age. I guess they didn't do anything illegal, but bribery seems unethical to me. If we are really concerned about democracy, we shouldn't tolerate the trampling of states' rights like this.
Actually, I think all this happened before I was born. I can still be mad though :)
Re:Is it time to lower America's drinking age?
by eat_my_shorts on Monday April 21, 2008 @02:12PM
(#169695)
States did that because of federal pressure, denying them federal dollars if they didn't. It was unilateral.
Re:Is it time to lower America's drinking age?
by epi0Bauqu on Monday April 21, 2008 @03:24PM
(#169772)
The US government does that all the time with a variety of laws using threats of highway money and other things. That is just politics--it doesn't make it unilateral. Sometimes states refuse, sometimes they don't. And sometimes the Federal government backs down. Not all states have a drinking age at 21 so there is sort of a control here and it goes the other way, i.e. I bet they are still getting federal highway money.
Also, I don't see how most other countries fixing it at a certain age is a strong argument for us to do so.