Re:Why We're Teaching 'The Wire' at Harvard
by jacobolus on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @12:40AM
(#1693332)
One thing every historian learns early on is that there are no perfect sources, no single narrative. (Go watch the film Memento if you want to see some fantastic philosophical musing on this topic: we can’t ever completely trust things written in the past, especially after we’ve lost the full context of an author’s motivation) The real world is big and complicated and messy. One thing a show like The Wire gets to do that would be nearly impossible for an academic paper is follow dozens of characters, their relationships, their private lives, their motivations, their interactions with public institutions.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why We're Teaching 'The Wire' at Harvard
by philwelch on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @02:14AM
(#1693478)
One thing a show like The Wire gets to do that would be nearly impossible for an academic paper is follow dozens of characters, their relationships, their private lives, their motivations, their interactions with public institutions.
Sounds like an ethnography, actually. This is exactly what anthropologists do in the field.
Re:Why We're Teaching 'The Wire' at Harvard
by jacobolus on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @03:25AM
(#1693597)
My parents are anthropologists, and you’re certainly sort of right. I maintain though that tracking dozens of drug dealers, cops, high-level city officials, newspaper reporters, unionized dockworkers letting drugs through as a side business, junior high students, etc. etc. would be almost impossible to do to the level of detail portrayed in The Wire – it would be difficult and dangerous work and you couldn’t get that kind of access (public officials don’t admit illegal activity as a rule), etc.
Of course, you’d be getting a glimpse at some real people, instead of a complete in-depth view of fictional ones.
Re:Why We're Teaching 'The Wire' at Harvard
by WalterBright on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @02:43AM
(#1693538)
Isn't that like saying studying real world physics is hard, so we'll study Star Trek instead?
Re:Why We're Teaching 'The Wire' at Harvard
by jacobolus on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @03:30AM
(#1693609)
It’s a pretty strained analogy either way, but it’s much more like saying studying protein folding is hard so we use some mix of (only roughly accurate) mathematical models and (imprecise, difficult to collect) experimental data, and hope we get close enough to still draw some meaningful conclusions.
Re:Why We're Teaching 'The Wire' at Harvard
by WalterBright on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @05:32AM
(#1693749)
If studying real relationships is so hard, how can you tell if the made up ones are valid?
Re:Why We're Teaching 'The Wire' at Harvard
by jacobolus on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @06:11AM
(#1693797)
Well, since the point of this TV drama is to make people think about the problems of urban life, the ways in which institutions behave, etc., it doesn’t have to be a perfect depiction of events to achieve that purpose; and indeed it could never be: a real city doesn’t only live in hour-long chunks, and has millions of people, not dozens.
But one pretty good way to get feedback is to see what people say who have been in similar circumstances and social situations. Everything I’ve heard suggests that the Wire is extremely believable.
Re:Why We're Teaching 'The Wire' at Harvard
by WalterBright on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @02:01PM
(#1695197)
Why can a hollywood script writer do this while Harvard research academics cannot?