Edit: just to back my point up; most of the people who I have seen who have tried to move to Linux have done a relatively sharpish 180 when the UI pokes them in the eye (gnome or unity)
If GNOME 3 didn't exist, I wouldn't be using Linux on the desktop.
People who have positive things to say about systemd have learned long ago to stay away from most discussions about it on places like Hacker News, because they'll just get drive-by-downvoted.
They're still around, and they still like (or at least appreciate) systemd; you just won't see them commenting much on those sorts of threads.
There are a lot of valid reasons to criticise systemd.
However, actually discussing those requires a level of nuance and consideration of the trade-offs involved, especially around forward progress versus reliability, that seems in this case to invariably get utterly derailed by screaming assholery from the far ends of the spectrum.
(signed, somebody who has more negative than positive things to say about systemd, but has also given up trying to engage about such things on here)
Most of the annoyances mentioned on the review can be altered using the Tweak tool or have extensions that change the behavior anyway.
To each his own, though. I don't understand why people like the OP find it impossible to imagine that other people are fine with, or even actually love, Gnome 3.