Re:64-bit Tiano Core UEFI for the Raspberry Pi 3
by andreiw on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @02:20PM
(#16924435)
Author here.
If you wanted to run you own drivers, or had code written specifically against protocols exported by Tiano components I believe the answer is - yes.
RaspberryPiPkg is the $35 64-bit Arm UEFI devkit.
Of couse the U-boot implementation of UEFI spec is getting better and better day by day, and that’s obviously awesome. I am sure someone will add ACPI support to it any day now. Having choice is good, and I wouldn’t want to live in a world with a single implementation. That said, Tiano (like it or not) /is/ the reference implementation, and you’re much less likely to run into surprises (today). Notice how I didn’t say Tiano is /better/, because in a number of ways (code quality, complexity, fragmentation) it’s pretty awful.
One thing the U-boot implementation excels at is embedded Arm board support - U-boot is the defacto firmware for most embedded hardware, and now all of that hardware is EFI-capable. Porting Tiano is effort you don’t want to spend.
That said, there are hybrid approaches - EFIDroid (efidroid.org) runs Tiano on top of LK, using LK’s platform support for drivers.
If you wanted to run you own drivers, or had code written specifically against protocols exported by Tiano components I believe the answer is - yes.
RaspberryPiPkg is the $35 64-bit Arm UEFI devkit.
Of couse the U-boot implementation of UEFI spec is getting better and better day by day, and that’s obviously awesome. I am sure someone will add ACPI support to it any day now. Having choice is good, and I wouldn’t want to live in a world with a single implementation. That said, Tiano (like it or not) /is/ the reference implementation, and you’re much less likely to run into surprises (today). Notice how I didn’t say Tiano is /better/, because in a number of ways (code quality, complexity, fragmentation) it’s pretty awful.
One thing the U-boot implementation excels at is embedded Arm board support - U-boot is the defacto firmware for most embedded hardware, and now all of that hardware is EFI-capable. Porting Tiano is effort you don’t want to spend.
That said, there are hybrid approaches - EFIDroid (efidroid.org) runs Tiano on top of LK, using LK’s platform support for drivers.