If you need a heart transplant, and I know you need a heart transplant, you're in kind of a lousy position to negotiate, aren't you?
I don't buy some Defense tokens or insurance on some market. I pay taxes for National Defense.
Don't get me wrong, capitalism is awesome. And I worked in healthcare software for about 13 years. But applying capitalism to basic, necessary healthcare is no good.
Imagine saying, do you want a $300 used iPhone or a $600 used iPhone? Pick one. You don't have enough information to make the decision but at least you know the price difference.
How about ... both? Knowing "outcomes" AND pricing would allow me to made an educated decision. Lacking one, or the other? Not so much.
Forcing people to decide "For $5,000 more, I have a 2% greater 5-year survivability" is inhumane.
We can do better. Other countries have done better. Our healthcare is more expensive, and our outcomes are worse. Capitalism does not work in healthcare.
What do you think Sanofi is exactly? That's the giant French pharma corporation that sells drugs in a global healthcare market.
How about all the excellent German medtech device makers? They sell their products in a global healthcare market.
How about Switzerland, Germany, Japan? They all have regulated healthcare markets, and they're three of the best healthcare systems on earth.
If you're a radiologist in the EU, you're selling your skill in a market. If one country won't pay you what you want, you can try to go to another market and earn more.
If businesses want to produce goods and services that governments pay for, in order to provide healthcare to the citizens, that's great.
Now, outcome data is probably not available for every single procedure.
Which is better, a CT Scan for $1000 or one for $10,000?
You probably guessed the cheaper one, right? Thinking "all CT Scans are the same," right? I happen to know that's not remotely true, but it's easy to think that saving money on a test would make sense, right?
Okay, now which is better, open-heart surgery for $20,000 or $200,000?
That's a lot harder to answer, isn't it?
You need to know the outcomes of those procedures at that facility, compared to other facilities, to have any possible way to judge them.