It's fair to say tribalism has always been around. And from that perspective, the current tribalism, including left-wing identity politics, is extremely reactionary.
A few things are, if not new, at least notable in this case:
* These people aren't historically outsiders, they're "heartland" Americans.
* The cultural narrative hasn't caught up to the cultural reality yet. For example, if child of meth heads grows up to be president, he's yet another privileged white president, not an outsider who overcame adversity. "Multicultural" attitudes group him in with Warren Buffett.
* There's no language, even to describe white people short on privilege. There are certainly slurs, but nothing you'd put on a questionnaire.
* The general direction of American culture has been to include more and more, however slowly. This is certainly a regression in that respect. And it seems to be accompanied by an abandonment of the ideal of inclusion qua inclusion. Instead, we seem to have a list of historically disadvantaged groups, telling newly disadvantaged groups that they already had their chance. Again, this is nonsense to an unemployed daughter of opiate addicts.
> For example, if child of meth heads grows up to be president, he's yet another privileged white president, not an outsider who overcame adversity.
It's racism and nothing else. Thing is, it's OK to be racist nowadays, as long as you're a liberal.
Edit: to the guy quoting the dictionary below me, this is racism in a really obvious way. It is "prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism directed against someone of a different race" and it's not okay just because you don't explicitly declare your race superior.
Then there is the soft bigotry of low expectations that’s famous among the left: “oh, these people are of a certain. race, so we don’t expect them to be able to pass this test or accomplish this goal.”
Bigotry and racism on the left is not as obvious, but I would argue, even more insidious.
These people were called out (or continue to be called out) for their actions and words, and unlike their counter parts on the right had the intelligence to correct for it. Whether you believe it to be sincere is kind of irrelevant, so I'm just going to stave off that talking point right there. Notable "leftist" institutions like the SPLC track such statements and view points and won't play disingenuous games with who they point a spotlight on.
>but I would argue, even more insidious.
Please do. I'd love to see how "bigotry" on the left is somehow equivalent to the decades of economic and social policies advanced by the right+ in the U.S.; policies that have quite literally decimated entire communities across the nation via incarceration, lack of education, and lack of capital access.
And what economic policies are racist in the US? If you admit that there are racist economic policies, then you are admitting that black people are somehow a homogenous group — which is itself racist. Black people aren’t different from white people, suggesting that they need special economic consideration is insulting.
Poor people isn’t analogous with black people, despite what Democrats would have you think.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Byrd#Ku_Klux_Klan
> But they have been far from leaders when it comes to civil rights. Martin Luther King, Jr was a Republican.
No he wasn't. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Luther_King_Jr.#Politic...
>then you are admitting that black people are somehow a homogenous group — which is itself racist
No that's not what that means at all, it means policies were targeted specifically at black people. "You're the REAL racist." is not a great talking point and further illustrates what an absolute loon you are.
>Poor people isn’t analogous with black people, despite what Democrats would have you think.
How confused do you have to be to make this statement with sincerity?
Dictionary definition:
>prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism directed against someone of a different race based on the belief that one's own race is superior.
Plenty of societies have extremely durable, endogamous tribal identifiers and they got along fine. This is true of India, China, The Ottoman Empire, and so on.
India, in particular, has some of the most durable and persistent forms of tribalism around, with castes having remained largely endogamus for centuries or more despite living, working, and trading with each other routinely.
Yet this didn't prevent them from alternating with China (itself extremely tribally divided despite the modern attempts to sweep it under the rug and cohere a "Han" nationality) at being the 1st or 2nd most prosperous civilization in the world for most of human history.
But more broadly, that's likely also true for culture and knowledge.
Yeah... but that's been going on forever. You see that with Muslims recently. We've seen that with hispanics. Further back, of course, we've been seeing it with blacks and native americans for a long time. That will ALWAYS happen.
The trick is to work out a way to keep moving forward even in the face of tribalism. Because I'm not entirely certain that we can eliminate tribalism. I'd love to be proven wrong, but I'm not sure that I will be.