Re:There are things more interesting than people
by bloak on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @09:27AM
(#16921320)
It's an exaggeration to claim that "almost every other literary genre is about character development". Detective, espionage and historical novels usually aren't "about" character development, I think, and those are probably the biggest genres if you exclude romance and sci-fi.
Of course one would expect to see some character development in a story that covers a large part of anyone's life but that doesn't make the story "about" character development.
Most so-called literary fiction (the stuff that gets lots of highbrow reviews, not so many sales, wins prizes this year and is totally forgotten in two years' time) tends to be about character development, perhaps even more so than romance.
Re:There are things more interesting than people
by automoton1 on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @02:31PM
(#16924545)
I think that in a lot of Sci-fi the people still play a critical role in the story, alongside the ideas. Not all sci-fi stories are about the ideas. They can often contain how the ideas impact people, how people use the ideas to shape their world and so on.
Re:There are things more interesting than people
by TeMPOraL on Friday April 27, 2018 @10:19AM
(#16940900)
I'm fine with that. I like people. I guess my main objection is against critics arguing sci-fi should look like regular old human story, but with sci-fi flavour. For me, the setting is an important part of the story, not just some irrelevant background styling.
Reminds me of when people criticize some sci-fi works for lacking in character development. My default response is: almost every other literary genre is about character development. I read sci-fi precisely because it's about ideas, about things more important than how people feel about each other. If I wanted to experience more of the interpersonal drama, I'd pick up a romance novel instead. Alas, I see enough of that in the real life.