News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Radical Markets by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @12:58AM (#16918722)
> Consider a system where property owners themselves specify what the value of their property is, and pay a tax rate of, say, 2% of that value per year. But here is the twist: whatever value they specify for their property, they have to be willing to sell it to anyone at that price

Valuing an asset takes work. The process consumes resources. There is a reason we have brokers for assets where one needs someone standing ready to auction. Making this proposal belies a fundamental misunderstanding of the history of markets.

Re:On Radical Markets by gojomo on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @01:34AM (#16918838)
But property taxes already face this challenge: the assessing authority has to specify a value – which may then be disputed by the property-owner in a costly appeals process.

This proposal lets the actor with the keenest interest and best knowledge of the property set a value, and lets the 'challenge' occur in the marketplace, by someone who's willing to buy it at that price. It lets the "brokers" and other experts of the world set the assessed value, by their actions (or potential actions), at a higher resolution than the current processes (which wait for actual sales or later bureaucratically-settled re-assessments).

Re:On Radical Markets by baddox on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @07:36AM (#16920558)
Not to mention that homeowners wanting to sell their home also face the same challenge: they need to assess the market and determine what they are willing to sell their home for.
Re:On Radical Markets by glifchits on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @02:15AM (#16918970)
Vitalik acknowledges your point:

"... people are not experts at property valuation, and would have to spend a significant amount of time and mental effort figuring out what self-assessed value to put for their house, and they would complain much more if they accidentally put a value that’s too low and suddenly find that their house is gone."

The solution: users would choose an AI to generate real time valuations.

In the property/personal home context, I think this is a bad idea, because if the AI gets it wrong, and you're forced to sell your house, that is bad. However, this idea could work very well in other types of property markets (this was all discussed in the article).

Re:On Radical Markets by snidane on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @03:37AM (#16919301)
There is clearly problem with the immediate nature of such market, that is being forced to move out quickly out of a property if one undervalues it.

Then there is clearly the problem with current market set up, which basically allows people to trade with infinite length property rights, especially on land. This gives incentive to buy and never sell, because you know that new generations will have to live somewhere and you will be the one able to provide this service. Esentially leading back to pure feudalism.

A middle ground solution could be to make the land market with land tax not immediate, ie. sell whenever someone else outbids you, but as auction for the property every, let's say, 7 years.

This would give you enough time to consider investing into the property withou losing it right away due to trivial underpricing. It would also solve the optimal property allocation, just on longer term. Another advantage for agricultural land would be that a piece of land couldn't enter the market unless it underwent the seventh sabbatical year of resting, which you could actually enforce under this system.

Re:On Radical Markets by bildung on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @05:25AM (#16919842)
* > The solution: users would choose an AI to generate real time valuations.*

Sadly this isn't a solution, it just adds another layer of complexity to the decision making process. AI isn't magically unbiased, there's a multitude of ways for human bias/ particular interests to enter the model, from feature selection to model layout up to interpretation of the results.

So now people have to be both experts at assessing housing and neighborhood values and AI to make an informed decision.

That's the big problem of market-based social designs: There's always the fundamental asymmetry between a professional, better-equipped actor (a corporation specialized in that particular market, or a rich person like the bezos example, who can outsource that to employees) and a normal person.

Regulation, society's solution to that problem, tries to level the field: People knowledgable in the problem domain think about possible negative externalities and risks to citizens, and implemenent barriers for abuse.

Re:On Radical Markets by glifchits on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @10:53AM (#16922025)
Normally I would agree with you completely, indeed AI is (very) far from perfect. However, I think we're hung up on the home property example. As Vitalik suggests, this proposal works a lot better in situations where the underlying property is more fungible, and the participants in the market are more or less equal. The property example I like from the article is radio spectrum licenses.

I'd also add that using an AI also doesn't necessarily mean something opaque. A hand-made decision tree would be preferable to a neural net, for example. The decision tree could prompt you for your human decision if it encounters an outlying, uncertain instance.

Re:On Radical Markets by bildung on Thursday April 26, 2018 @03:58AM (#16929836)
I actually find the housing problem quite apt, because it so easily illustrates the problem of information asymmetry of the market participants. If you can't guarantee that, you don't have an efficient market. How can you prevent that, if not with the help of protection through law (i.e. regulation)?
Re:On Radical Markets by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @09:00AM (#16921107)
> this idea could work very well in other types of property markets

Constantly offering to the market is market making. It's a difficult, risky and specialized domain in any asset classes. Most markets cannot support real-time market making for the simple reason that price discovery is expensive and intrinsically tied to liquidity.