News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by coryl on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:37PM (#1691707)
Working on this project with a friend. Any suggestions?
Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by lmkg on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @03:15PM (#1691875)
Data scrubbing. For example:

  California:
  High Quality: $359.19 / oz. (n=72)
  Medium Quality: $300 / oz. (n=17)
  Low Quality: $648 / oz. (n=2)     <-- ???
The low quality stuff is worth more than twice as much as the medium? The crazy numbers for low quality are on account of one wonky data point ($976/oz). There were also some obviously bunk ones like $1/oz, which someone probably did pay from a friend, but that doesn't reflect street value.

It's hard to do this in an automated fashion, though, at least until you have a good amount of data. A good place to start would be automatically flagging figures more than 2 standard deviations from the (local) mean, and hand-curating those. Keep track of "bad" data points, and as you find patterns you can add filters.

Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by coryl on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @03:23PM (#1691909)
Yep, we haven't gotten around to filtering and cleaning up entries, but we'll definitely look to eliminate big outliers from our average calculations.

A lot of people have been pointing on the same thing you've been pointing out lol. That's why we added the n= for the time being.

Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by Alex3917 on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @04:07PM (#1692083)
The price for the High Quality doesn't make much sense either even with tons of data points. According to Yelp the most expensive dispensary in SF is Divinity Tree, and I think their onces are $360. Considering that basically everywhere else in the state should be cheaper than this I don't see how the average could possibly be 360.
Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by coryl on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @04:16PM (#1692101)
Not everyone can get licenses to purchase from dispensaries, so a dispensary's price is not necessarily market price. Theres still a "black" market so to speak; of people who buy it illegally.
Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by Alex3917 on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @05:50PM (#1692467)
Yes, but the black market price is usually cheaper than the dispensary price.
Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by coryl on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @06:14PM (#1692535)
Not entirely true. If I can't get a license, I have to buy off the black market; meaning I have to go through dealers who traffic under the risk of arrest and prosecution. That creates the premium price that drugs have today, everywhere. Thus it makes sense for a drug dealer to charge more than the price available legally, because buyers without licenses have no choice.

However, there are also demand and supply side things going on that we might not know about that is affecting the price.

Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by jrockway on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @08:28PM (#1692831)
Not entirely true. If I could buy pot at the dispensary and my friend couldn't, I'd just buy it for him and split it down the middle.
Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by coryl on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @09:43PM (#1692996)
Yeah, but you have to look at the big picture. Not everyone has friends with licenses. Your still doing a favor for a friend and breaking the law, meaning you deserve a premium on the resale (not that you'd take anything from a friend).
Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by Alex3917 on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @10:43AM (#1694339)
In California illegal weed is cheaper than legal weed. That's just an empirical fact. It doesn't matter if you think it shouldn't be this way, that's just how it is.
Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by coryl on Thursday September 16, 2010 @08:00PM (#1699549)
Source of empirical fact?
Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by evgen on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @03:27PM (#1691921)
I think one problem you will run into is that you are attempting to compare prices while also keeping fuzzy distinctions like quality. Alabama has cheaper "high quality" weed than California? That tells me that what would sell for $400/oz in CA is not available at any price in AL.

If you cut out the user-supplied quality metric or figure out some way to try to normalize this across the samples (e.g. ask submitters if they have purchased in other states and how they would rank this purchase against that past purchase) you would probably get better useful data.

Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by coryl on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @03:33PM (#1691943)
Indeed, quality is highly subjective and relative to product available on the market. I have a personal hypothesis that most average smokers can't distinguish high quality vs medium quality.

I'm not sure how practical it is to get users to try and compare product quality from different locations; the sample size would probably be very low because most people buy and consume where they live.

Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by evgen on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @06:06PM (#1692517)
True. I was mostly suggesting that you should drop the quality distinction but trying to leave you an out in case there was some clever way to normalize this. I think that in general people would find an accurate average more useful because then they could perform any quality discounting on their own using the known basepoint.
Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by dgc on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @06:35PM (#1692591)
I actually think there could be some objective quality measures, but you would need someone with a fair range of experience to judge. Perhaps number of buds per ounce in the mix or a simple color/image chart to select from?
Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by c23gooey on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @07:54PM (#1692750)
a simpler distinction would be whether the marijuana is outdoor or hydroponically grown
Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by jRoden on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @04:19PM (#1692115)
The problem with compiling an overall $/oz. amount is that, generally, prices go down as quantity goes up. The data will be skewed if a lot of people are reporting $50 eighths (400/oz.) and the price for an ounce from the same dealer is, say, $300. Maybe track the different amounts separately?
Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by coryl on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @04:28PM (#1692155)
Exactly, we aren't incorporating the volume discount when we scale up smaller quantities of weed. This is because we really just don't know what the average margins of sales between different quantities.

We could display the averages in each quantity, but it would lack enough sample size. Plus having one nice round number is easier to visualize. I think the final .oz average probably within +/-10% accuracy.

Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by dgc on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @06:38PM (#1692604)
publishing the standard deviation on the normalized price would go a long way towards making the numbers more useful. If you get enough samples you can do a simple fit to attempt to quantify the discount rate.
Re:Google Maps visualization of marijuana prices, with over ... by sv123 on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @04:51PM (#1692268)
I only ever buy a single gram, but can't put that in. Also what if vendors start putting prices they pay growers, and dispensaries enter prices from vendors, and customers use prices from dispensaries... The same batch of herb will be many different prices, possibly need some way to distinguish a "type" of price that is being entered. That would make the data more valuable also for dispensaries shopping around different vendors, etc. Of course that is sticking to the "legal" weed market.