Re:Patent Review System Upheld by U.S. Supreme Court
by burkaman on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @02:57PM
(#16915539)
That makes sense, but I don't think it explains why Supreme Court decisions can change so drastically. What changed between Cumming v. Richmond County Board of Education and Brown v. Board of Education? What changed between Pace v. Alabama and Loving v. Virginia?
I can think of a few possibilities:
1. Pre-1950s courts were consistently incompetent and didn't understand the meaning of the 14th amendment.
2. Pre-1950s courts were consistently malicious and deliberately ignored the meaning of the 14th amendment.
3. Pre-1950s courts were correct about the meaning, and post-1950s courts have universally abandoned originalism and now apply their own invented meaning of the 14th amendment.
4. The meaning of the 14th amendment changed.
Re:Patent Review System Upheld by U.S. Supreme Court
by wnoise on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @04:25PM
(#16916204)
My current conclusion is 2 and bit of 1 via overly deferent stare decisis.
In fact, there was a short span of time immediately post civil war where civil rights were effectively enforced in the South. Reconstruction ended too soon.
A pure originalist might look to what the framers of the 14th amendment thought they were doing, but most people we would call originalists today would look to what the text of the 14th amendment meant at the time it was written.
> If you think that everyone before 1954 was interpreting the amendment incorrectly, that's equivalent to saying that the generally accepted meaning of the text changed
People often write things that mean something different than what the text says. (I'll point to FOSTA/SESTA as a contemporary example. 98% of the people who voted for it are thinking that its directed at sites actively promoting sex trafficking, but by its plain terms it applies to anyone "facilitating" sex trafficking, which is a much broader word.)