News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Patent Review System Upheld by U.S. Supreme Court by rayiner on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @12:28PM (#16914050)
Imagine you're married, and you agree with your wife about certain basic rules of the relationship, procedures for resolving disputes, etc. Should those basic rules be up for debate when, years later, you're having a heated argument about something? And if so, who gets to decide how to change those rules?

The Constitution is the same way. It's a check on democracy, but it's also democratic: "we agreed to do it this way, and if we want to change a rule we have to reach a new agreement through a cool-headed process."

In this case, the Constitution creates limits on what kinds of things may be resolved by the executive branch, and what must be done by the courts. That allocation of power between branches is not something we want to leave to whatever people think is a good idea on any given day. As to why we look to 18th century England: the founders thought that English courts worked pretty well, so they basically forked English common law. So sometimes, to understand our own law we look to what the English courts were doing before we made our own fork.

Sometimes you like the end result, sometimes you don't. Sometimes originalism means that a terrorist who is a U.S. citizen has to get a jury trial in an Article III court, even if the prevailing public opinion is that those people should be tried in military tribunals.

Re:Patent Review System Upheld by U.S. Supreme Court by contras1970 on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @08:18AM (#16920797)
> Imagine you're married, and you agree with your wife about certain basic rules of the relationship, procedures for resolving disputes, etc. Should those basic rules be up for debate when, years later, you're having a heated argument about something? And if so, who gets to decide how to change those rules?

I don't think we're talking about patents granted by the crown in 17th-18th century, so if you wanted to make this analogy it'd have to go like this:

Imagine you're gay, and you want to get married. Should basic rules of marriage be up for debate when, thousands years ago, society agreed that gay people should be killed instead?

Re:Patent Review System Upheld by U.S. Supreme Court by DataWorker on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @10:34AM (#16921837)
So you’ll be totally content if 20 years from now society decides that gay people should not be allowed to marry?
Re:Patent Review System Upheld by U.S. Supreme Court by contras1970 on Thursday April 26, 2018 @01:01PM (#16933625)
some 30 years ago i could ask you: so you'll be totally content if 20 years from now society decides that gay people should be allowed to marry?

i'm not really sure what your point is. are you arguing that societal changes should be prohibited? well then: is the recent change towards equalization of gay people's rights ok? why? because you like it?

so, let's say we base our reasoning about our present-day society on the culture of 17xx AD England, because change is bad. well, we will have to roll back women's vote to right, not to mention all the modern nonsense that "negroes" are allowed today. but why stop at 17xx AD England: that society was the result of many changes from 10xx AD England. lots of change, and we've established that change is bad. but don't stop there: even 10xx AD England was a product of changes, and changes are bad...

btw, the answer to that non-sequitur of yours is "no i wouldn't." but i have to accept the bad with the good. democracy helped Hitler to the Chancellor title. i don't think we should get rid of democracy to prevent another Hitler.

Re:Patent Review System Upheld by U.S. Supreme Court by DataWorker on Thursday April 26, 2018 @06:09PM (#16936341)
I guess I’m saying that societal views on the acceptability of homosexuality have waxed and waned quite a bit, but everyone knows the history. My larger point was that mobs can be quite fickle and for that reason we’ve seen fit to base our jurisprudence on more immutable principals. This I’d argue is an improvement worthy of recognition and protection.
Re:Patent Review System Upheld by U.S. Supreme Court by dbasedweeb on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @12:31PM (#16914085)
Except in this case it’s like being forced to resolve disputes according to your uncle’s inexpert and biased reading of how your great-great-great-great-grandparents settles their marital spats.
Re:Patent Review System Upheld by U.S. Supreme Court by tptacek on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @02:07PM (#16915028)
It is not. The Privy Council example rebuts one of Greene Energy's arguments. The foundation of the decision is orthogonal to that rebuttal; it's simply that issuance of a patent franchise doesn't turn a public right into private property, and thus what the USPTO giveth, the USPTO can taketh away.
Re:Patent Review System Upheld by U.S. Supreme Court by dbasedweeb on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @06:18PM (#16917153)
I’m not disagreeing with the majority decision, just the argument for originalism.
Re:Patent Review System Upheld by U.S. Supreme Court by DannyBee on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @12:34AM (#16918653)
The argument against anything else is that they all turn the court into a policy making body in various forms, instead of trying to stay as objective about interpretation as they can.

Whether that's good or bad depends on your view.

Re:Patent Review System Upheld by U.S. Supreme Court by dbasedweeb on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @12:36PM (#16923265)
Objective and originalist are different things, and the constitution has never been immutable, hence the large number of amendments.
Re:Patent Review System Upheld by U.S. Supreme Court by neekburm on Friday April 27, 2018 @08:47AM (#16940364)
I think this was a tactic by the defenders of IPR, rather than some deeply-held belief. We have at least four self-styled originalists (but see https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1422048) on the Court, and they want to hear arguments about what 18th Century politicians thought about patent rights.
Re:Patent Review System Upheld by U.S. Supreme Court by DannyBee on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @12:22AM (#16918609)
That's not a fair characterization. Thomas for example, while i don't always agree with him, does try to do real research on the history of these issues/subjects. He's also not exactly "inexpert". It's not bullshit attempts to rationalize an ideology (like say, Gorusch, AFAICT :P).

If he's wrong about history, and you can show it, he's generally been willing to change his view.

As mentioned, they also definitely rely on experts for this (and are often experts themselves), and cite the expert historical analysis they rely upon.

Re:Patent Review System Upheld by U.S. Supreme Court by lainga on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @01:02PM (#16914414)
If you disagree with the majority opinions of the Justices, who were nominated under Reagan, Bush Sr. and Jr., Clinton, and Obama, you are free to vote for a president who will appoint differently-minded justices (like Justice Gorsuch, who was nominated by Trump).
Re:Patent Review System Upheld by U.S. Supreme Court by dbasedweeb on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @06:18PM (#16917148)
I agree with the decision actually, I just disagree with the originalist viewpoint.