Re:Europe’s New Privacy Rules Favor Google and Facebook
by LoSboccacc on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @01:08PM
(#16914475)
> when you link it with other data.
> reasonably able
it clearly states 'legal means' to identify the user. a subpoena is a perfectly reasonable and legal way to disclose an identity from an ip and doesn't require access to any other personal data, merely that such a link from ip to identity exists. the link is the "third party information to identify the user". it's not that you correlate an ip with a cookie or other technical means. you have to get out of the engineering mindset.
> an internet service provider ("ISP") has a record of the temporary "dynamic IP address" assigned to a particular user's device (potentially identifiable data); and
Here they're not talking about "IP addresses", they're talking about "IP addresses assigned to particular users".
> In answering the BGH’s first question, the ECJ confirmed that dynamic IP addresses are considered personal data within the meaning of the Directive in circumstances where the data collector (e.g., a website operator) is likely or reasonably able to obtain information from a third party that would allow it to identify the user.
This clearly says that an IP address by itself is not personal information. It only becomes personal information when you can identify a natural person - when you link it with other data.