Re:Europe’s New Privacy Rules Favor Google and Facebook
by rectang on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @01:54AM
(#16910211)
I'm OK with that and I accept that cost, because in my eyes stopping the savage victimization of users is worthwhile. For you (or the WSJ) to persuade me that the GDPR is problematic, I'd have to believe that first, that's something that those opposed to the GDPR actually care about, and that it's something that could be achieved through other means.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Europe’s New Privacy Rules Favor Google and Facebook
by chrischen on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @02:10AM
(#16910280)
Except this does nothing to really stop the savage victimization of users by Facebook or Google. If anything it solidifes their dominance.
The abuses are happening from these big companies, not the thousands of tiny startups that live and die within months that have a few hundred thousand users.
Re:Europe’s New Privacy Rules Favor Google and Facebook
by rectang on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @02:26AM
(#16910357)
So your proposal is a return to the status quo ante and unlimited exploitation of users? Not good enough. I will take the imperfect good of the GDPR as an incremental improvement over the option of abject surrender.
Re:Europe’s New Privacy Rules Favor Google and Facebook
by woolvalley on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @03:59AM
(#16910767)
No the proposal is to apply the GDPR to the large organizations that can afford to implement it properly. It's not black and white ;)
Re:Europe’s New Privacy Rules Favor Google and Facebook
by AstralStorm on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @11:23PM
(#16918437)
GDPR is not applied indiscriminately you know. It has various responsibilities indeed depending on company and/or database size.
Re:Europe’s New Privacy Rules Favor Google and Facebook
by tjoff on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @03:18AM
(#16910569)
Actually, it does. Thanks to GPDR you now has to opt in to allow facebook to track you in photos etc.
And startups that exploit users don't really provide much of anything anyway.
Re:Europe’s New Privacy Rules Favor Google and Facebook
by chrischen on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @01:31PM
(#16914673)
Facebook’s harm comes from wasting your time and putting you in an echo chamber of agreeable people and agreeable thoughts.
They can make it all opt-in fairly easily as a requirement for using certain features. People will blindly click and continue like normal.
Re:Europe’s New Privacy Rules Favor Google and Facebook
by tjoff on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @05:33PM
(#16916825)
Well, there are tons of people that use facebook to the smallest extent possible and that only because they are forced if they want to be informed of certain events etc. This is a huge step in the right direction for a lot of people.
Re:Europe’s New Privacy Rules Favor Google and Facebook
by dvfjsdhgfv on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @02:23AM
(#16910343)
This argument is of the "we can't solve the problem completely, so let's do nothing about it" kind. The abuse is happening from both camps and we all know it, especially here on HN where some of us are actively developing user-tracking schemes and ad-targeting platforms for a living.
Re:Europe’s New Privacy Rules Favor Google and Facebook
by nemothekid on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @02:38AM
(#16910420)
IMO, it's less "both camps are doing it" and more have we now insulated these giants from any future competition.
For example, how do the decentralized social platforms (mastadon, diaspora), exist under GDPR?
Re:Europe’s New Privacy Rules Favor Google and Facebook
by AstralStorm on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @03:35AM
(#16910653)
Under explicit consent of the people putting the data in. All this needs is a nice informative screen on how the data will be used and that it will be publicly available, which may mean being processed by other registered users and unknown third parties.
The networks will not be able to process the data in other ways than making it available.
If you break someone's privacy laws you will be liable directly.
Probably also a note that data on this network cannot be completely deleted for specific technical reasons.