Bain and KKR's turn-round strategy was largely a joke: They basically floated a bunch of trial balloons to the press, arguing that they weren't going to just be a toy store anymore (basically become a walmart or target) but that was scuttled. After that, they just decided to control costs as tightly as possible. Very little innovation.
Prior to the buyout, there was a team inside Toys 'R' Us that was trying to clone Amazon's e-commerce success. It died with the buyout. Bain and KKR thought they had a better plan: they didn't.
If we flipped roles, with the team inside Toys 'R' Us trying to control costs before the PE firms came in and tried to make Amazon competitor, it would sound equally damning.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/overheard-amd-cutting-costs-141...
Everyone wins except for whomever was stuck holding the bag on the debt.
Maybe. It was already on a downward spiral. There's pretty much zero evidence that, left as a public company, they'd have figured out a way to reboot. It's not like there aren't plenty of other retail chains in dire straits.