Re:Google has started the global roll-out of its new Chat me...
by zwily on Monday April 23, 2018 @08:46AM
(#16902890)
That article does not say that Apple is encrypting the per-message key with an Apple public key (alongside the device-specific keys), just that it could. Yes, there are many ways Apple could bypass its own E2E encryption, but we haven’t seen any evidence that it is or has.
Re:Google has started the global roll-out of its new Chat me...
by _o_ on Monday April 23, 2018 @09:04AM
(#16903020)
Well, the point of E2E encryption is that you cant bypass it. That only the recipient is able to read it. Believe me that if I start making e2e encryption, no one will bypass it and I doubt the engineers at Apple are not able to do it, unless instructed otherwise.
I will tell you another case: Skype. It had a p2p protocol, highly encrypted and obfuscated, also the application was armored. The communication wasn't going through Skype servers but directly between devices. Once Microsoft bought it, the next version was using Microsoft servers and p2p was gone. Interesting, right?
Re:Google has started the global roll-out of its new Chat me...
by zwily on Monday April 23, 2018 @10:56AM
(#16903916)
I'd be curious to hear a proposal on how Apple could implement an E2E encrypted messaging service in a way that it would be impossible for them to circumvent it in the future via a software update. I suspect it's not possible, and therefore, either you accept some trust in Apple and take their model as "good enough" or you don't trust them at all (meaning you don't use iOS or macOS). There are, of course, lots of people that do that. But for most the population of iOS users, I think the iMessage model is very much good enough.
Re:Google has started the global roll-out of its new Chat me...
by jhasse on Monday April 23, 2018 @06:24PM
(#16908034)
> I'd be curious to hear a proposal on how Apple could implement an E2E encrypted messaging service in a way that it would be impossible for them to circumvent it in the future via a software update.
Open source. And for really impossible also open hardware.
Re:Google has started the global roll-out of its new Chat me...
by newscracker on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @01:34AM
(#16910100)
How would anyone validate what exactly is running on the servers at any point in time so that you can trust it every single second? At some point, it comes down to trusting someone or the other.
Before you start downvoting spree, read this:
For Apple: https://mashable.com/2013/10/17/apple-nsa-imessage
http://bgr.com/2015/08/06/iphone-fbi-imessage-facetime-backd...
https://www.tripwire.com/state-of-security/latest-security-n...
For WhatsApp: https://tobi.rocks/
(encrypt data with random key with symmetric encryption algorythm (AES,...), which is then encrypted and stored with the mesage twice. Once encrypted with recipient public key (asymmetric: RSA,ECC) and once encrypted with apple public key. This way you can say that you are having end to end encryption while you can still read everything and you can also use all the nice words in marketing material, AES, end2end, RSA/ECC,...).