News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Be Good by mhb on Sunday April 20, 2008 @10:49PM (#169012)
Would you consider Octopart evil if they deny my request for their code/data so I that I can duplicate their site in order to provide an improved customer/vendor experience?
Re:Be Good by pg on Monday April 21, 2008 @12:58AM (#169096)
That would be more like asking Digi-Key for the contents of their warehouses.
Re:Be Good by wensing on Monday April 21, 2008 @08:41AM (#169323)
No. Digi-Key and certain other parts companies are suppliers, not manufacturers; hence they are in the information business. Octopart is really an aggregator of aggregators. Should we expect Orbitz to make their content available to MyNewTravelStartup.com?
Re:Be Good by smock on Monday April 21, 2008 @11:49AM (#169471)
I'm not sure I understand - Octopart does not sell any parts. Digi-Key's core function is to sell parts. They do in fact have a warehouse of parts and a team of salespeople, whereas we are three guys working out of cafes. Our interests certainly overlap to a high degree in that we both want accurate part information. But Digi-Key is in the information business in the same way that Walmart is in the information business (a company that also re-sells most of its inventory from manufacturers in its supply chain).
Re:Be Good by wensing on Monday April 21, 2008 @12:06PM (#169499)
Digi-Key's strategy obviously diverges from Wal-Mart when we look at profit margins.

You make a good point; I don't think I can argue against what Octopart is trying to do from any kind of good vs. evil ethical standpoint. However, I can understand a business such as Digi-Key wanting to maintain control, and they could easily argue it is for the benefit of the customer. For example, when a customer searches Octopart, are they going to also get a list of complementary parts from each supplier? I doubt it. What about helpful charts, material safety data sheets, and CAD schematics? If someone was just scraping my site and hijacking the search functionality but failing to deliver the rest, I'm not sure I'd want my name attached either.

Of course this is really coming at it from the wrong level. The truth is that Digi-Key can simply ignore you, and it doesn't hurt them in the slightest. And while doing so, they can be sure they aren't reaping any of the negative consequences of being associated with you either.

Re:Be Good by andres on Monday April 21, 2008 @12:39PM (#169557)
The problem is not that Digi-Key is ignoring Octopart, but that they are making frivolous legal claims in order to rack up Octopart's legal bills. Digi-Key is acting the same way Microsoft did when they sued Linux for patent infringement.
Re:Be Good by smock on Monday April 21, 2008 @12:25PM (#169526)
This discussion of whether we are adding value or not seems very hypothetical to me. We aren't forcing anyone to use our site, presumably if people are using our site, it is because they find it useful.