Re:Google and Microsoft Push Websites to Go Password-Less
by hirsin on Sunday April 22, 2018 @08:07PM
(#16899463)
Authentication and Federated login shouldn't become the same thing, and FIDO doesn't move us closer to that. There's not a scenario where this becomes "silently login to Facebook and silently provide consent by clicking login" - users will still have to consciously click on "login with Facebook" at which point they can use FIDO to login to a Facebook property.
Another worry is that this sort of approach will effectively hide the authentication mechanism from the user. So while I may make the choice to use notional biometric login to a Facebook app on my phone, knowing all the risks and compromises that come with having a Facebook account, I may not wish to use a Facebook login for other authenticated services unrelated to Facebook (when I'm confronted with the option to log in with Facebook, I always choose the other option, whatever it is, even if it's "give up on using this system/service").