News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:American Drugs in Egyptian Mummies (2005) by jcranmer on Sunday April 22, 2018 @09:26AM (#16896060)
> Why is it so hard for some people of European descent to believe that non-European people may have crossed oceans in non-European ways, without Europeans ever hearing about it? For goodness sake, look at the pyramids. European people still aren't totally sure how those things were built. There are theories, but you don't know what's possible/impossible.

Well, saying that Norte Chico gave the Ancient Egyptians a hand with skycrane techniques is pretty impossible. There's a wide gap between "we're not sure what the answer is" and "this wild theory is equally well-supported by the evidence."

I gave some details in another comment, but the shipbuilding technology simply didn't exist before around 700 or so to cross the Atlantic Ocean--not in Europe, nor in the Americas (It did exist in Asia, but the Polynesian expansion and experience strongly limits the space for Asian trans-Pacific contact). That creates a very strong prior against pre-Columbian trans-oceanic contact, one that requires more persuasive evidence than "I can interpret this as a New World relic in the Old World." The only theory that comes close to meeting that standard is the Polynesian contact theory.

Re:American Drugs in Egyptian Mummies (2005) by macawfish on Sunday April 22, 2018 @01:29PM (#16897269)
The reason I posted that article from foreignpolicy.com is because I wanted people to see that there are other, related theories that they may not have considered. I see that you still have not considered this one!

The space of what is possible is overwhelmingly large, it frustrates me when "rationalism" means setting up these extreme categories of possible vs impossible, sane vs "crackpot", etc.

Re:American Drugs in Egyptian Mummies (2005) by throwaway413 on Sunday April 22, 2018 @10:20AM (#16896270)
> simply didn't exist before around 700 or so

You say that with such certainty as if you were there.

Re:American Drugs in Egyptian Mummies (2005) by opportune on Sunday April 22, 2018 @10:31AM (#16896317)
Well, there is no evidence for it aside from things like the article, which have simpler explanations. I can't be certain that the sun isn't a smiling baby when it's not being observed either
Re:American Drugs in Egyptian Mummies (2005) by throwaway413 on Sunday April 22, 2018 @11:09AM (#16896479)
There’s a big difference between a blatantly improbable conclusion in the present vs concluding something about the entirety of the situation here before 700.

All I’m saying is that a small bit of doubt is healthy.