News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by b6 on Saturday April 21, 2018 @12:10PM (#16891958)
> Buddhism is so audaciously and unapologetically male-dominated

From what I understand, the Buddha taught anyone who was interested without the slightest regard for gender, age, wealth, caste, or anything else -- 2500 years ago, in India.

The monastic orders have very reasonable rules about how new monks or nuns get legitimacy by being approved by former monks or nuns, and that worked for, I think, over a thousand years. The problem is, for some reason, the female lineage suffered a break, and there was no contingency plan for restoration. But this is now occurring, at least in Theravada. Please don't paint it as if Buddhism is sexist. It is actually amazingly and remarkably non-sexist, back in a time when this was unheard of.

Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by jrochkind1 on Saturday April 21, 2018 @03:14PM (#16892855)
From the OP:

> "...two-dimensional caricatures tend not to deepen. Instead, they flip – in this case, from loving and peaceful back to the sinister and violent caricatures that..."

Much like arguments over whether who and what is "real" Christianity, or Islam... it's all equally "real". Buddhism is made of people and has a couple thousand years of history across large swaths of the world. And like everything made of people, it's complex and has parts and times and trends we might like and parts we might not.

I suppose the believer can say the parts they don't like aren't 'real', and different factions of believers can fight it out over which parts are 'real', as in all religions. But that doesn't seem very "Buddhist" to me. :) And like with all religions or ideologies, the non-believer has no stake in the game. It's all equally "real Buddhism", as it's all things that have actually happened and been done by and in the name of Buddhism.

Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by paloaltokid on Saturday April 21, 2018 @12:26PM (#16892013)
I think the parent is talking about the people in the "ism" of Buddhism, not the Buddha himself. I think it's similar in Christianity. We have no idea what Christ believed, but his followers sure have had some regressive attitudes towards women.

Also, I'd agree with you that Buddhism itself is not sexist. But many of the practitioners are as sexist as everyone else. We shouldn't assume that just because someone practices a certain religion or spirituality that they are perfect.

Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by icebraining on Saturday April 21, 2018 @01:26PM (#16892299)
I don't think that's right. Christians do know what Christ believe - it's right there in the Bible.

I, as a non-Christian, might be skeptical of that, but believing it is part of the definition of Christian.

Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by paloaltokid on Saturday April 21, 2018 @02:06PM (#16892472)
As a former Christian, I don't think we have any real idea what Christ (the historical figure) actually believed. For instance, I never recall learning that Christ wanted a church to be established with a Vatican, a pope, cardinals, etc. Nor did Christ say anything about going to church on Sunday.

Most of the Bible is the Old Testament, which are primarily Jewish religious texts carried over from tradition, and the New Testament is a lot of writing about Christ from his disciples and later followers. But I found in my own study of the Bible that Christ was actually a fairly minor character, in terms of the volume of quotes actually directly attributed to him.

Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by icebraining on Saturday April 21, 2018 @02:40PM (#16892661)
Christ (the historical figure)

I'm not a current or ex-Christian, but except for Jehovah's Witnesses, do any current-day Christians believe that Christ is not (also) God himself? And isn't the New Testament the revealed Word of God? How could Christ-the-historical-figure have any opinions different from the ones revealed by God?

Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by dragonwriter on Saturday April 21, 2018 @08:27PM (#16894108)
> I'm not a current or ex-Christian, but except for Jehovah's Witnesses, do any current-day Christians believe that Christ is not (also) God himself?

Most Christians accept Trinitarianism as a definitional requirement for Christianity, hence why theologically-precise descriptions of JW and related groups, and LDS, and some other groups that describe themselves as Christian from within mainstream Christianity use phrases like “pseudo-Christian cults”. But, yes, there are certainly groups that self describe as Christian that subscribe to heterodox (from the POV of mainstream Christianity) Christology, and JW are very much not alone there.

> And isn't the New Testament the revealed Word of God?

No, Jesus Christ in the Word of God. The Bible (the whole thing, not just the NT) is words about God. The NT is just the part written after Christ and which looks back on him rather than forward to him.

> How could Christ-the-historical-figure have any opinions different from the ones revealed by God?

The Bible, in any case, contains very little direct explication of the opinions of Jesus, and those it does have are often opinions about specific events also recounted in the Bible. Most ideas about his general opinions that have any applicability outside of the narrow events in the Bible are inferences and generalizations from the Bible (or other sources in tradition; the Bible as the sole root of Christian belief is a fairly modern innovation in theology held by a narrow subset of Christianity, which also tends to have stronger views about the literalness and factual authority of the Bible than other Christians.)

Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by paloaltokid on Saturday April 21, 2018 @05:22PM (#16893517)
That's a great question and one that I'm not really qualified to answer. It's a huge theological topic, though.

In my own life, I don't identify as a Christian anymore but I continue to draw inspiration from Christ's life and the few teachings I felt I could attribute directly to him.

Even when I called myself a Christian, I never believed that the Bible was the literal word of God. It's just a book. When I studied for my confirmation my pastor took our group through a lot of interesting history around how the Bible was actually written and put together. There was tons of material that never made it in, so it's at best an approximation of beliefs that people who call themselves Christians have had over time.

For what it's worth the history of Christianity is fascinating. There were many schisms and lots of infighting within the Church even prior to the Reformation. I suspect the same may be true within Judaism and Islam - there are "mainstream" sets of beliefs and then people on the fringe. Likely the fringe folks were more tapped in to the real mystical teachings but got shut out.

Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by uhuh234 on Saturday April 21, 2018 @02:58PM (#16892761)
> do any current-day Christians believe that Christ is not (also) God himself?

Yes lots, they are known as Trinitarians. Those that don't believe that Jesus is God incarnate are non-Trinitarians. Without being disrespectful to those that know far more than I, this was basically (simplistically, more or less) the reason for the Schism or the Orthodox Christian Church.

Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by kgwgk on Saturday April 21, 2018 @04:03PM (#16893129)
Actually I think they were all Trinitarian and agreed on the nature of Christ. The disagreement was over the origin of the Holy Spirit. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Filioque
Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by icebraining on Saturday April 21, 2018 @03:47PM (#16893041)
Yes, I know (although I was actually asking about non-Trinitarians - sorry for the confusing formulation), but my question was if there were any "complete" non-Trinitarians left, except for Jehovah's Witnesses.
Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by neaden on Sunday April 22, 2018 @07:44PM (#16899364)
Mormons are non trinitarian.
Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by kgwgk on Saturday April 21, 2018 @04:05PM (#16893145)
Unitarians.
Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by psyc on Saturday April 21, 2018 @03:11PM (#16892836)
Jesus said a finite number of things in the New Testament, so we have interpretations of some of his thoughts on some things. Every fundamentalist church I attended when I was young was far more enthusiastic about the teachings of Paul.
Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by paloaltokid on Saturday April 21, 2018 @05:24PM (#16893524)
Yep! I think modern fundamentalist Christians are actually more disciples of Paul than they are Christ.
Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by icebraining on Saturday April 21, 2018 @03:51PM (#16893067)
Right, but Paul's writings is Scripture, which is Word of God, and Christ is God. How could Christ believe anything else?
Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by paloaltokid on Saturday April 21, 2018 @05:25PM (#16893535)
I think you may be overthinking this a little, or applying philosophical reasoning where it doesn't quite make sense.

If someone writes a book about me, that has nothing to do with me, even if the person who writes the book claims to know everything about me. Only I know what I believe and you should only assume I believe the things you hear me say, whether in word or in deed.

EDIT: also, Paul never actually met Christ. He came along later after Christ had already been crucified. If you believe Paul's account, Christ revealed himself in a vision. But everyone agrees that Paul and Christ never actually met in person.

Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by dragonwriter on Saturday April 21, 2018 @08:16PM (#16894086)
> I, as a non-Christian, might be skeptical of that, but believing it is part of the definition of Christian.

The Bible—specifically the Gospels —contains some stories about what Jesus said and did, but much of the former is explicitly in parable. Ideas about what Jesus thought are largely inferences from that.

And any belief about the Bible other than that, understood correctly, it contains no moral error, is neither part of the definition of Christianity, nor a universal doctrine within it (even among the official doctrines of the large subsets.)

Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by vkou on Saturday April 21, 2018 @04:05PM (#16893140)
Most of the Bible has nothing to do with Christ - and the parts that do were written down by people with their own biases.
Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by KingMob on Saturday April 21, 2018 @02:39PM (#16892657)
It's quite a bit more complicated than that, unfortunately.

First, the Pali canon didn't begin to be put to paper until 100-200 years after the buddha, so like Jesus, there aren't clear first-hand records.

That being said, the Pali canon states Buddha was reluctant to teach women, and had to be exhorted by his aunt to agree. Supposedly, he agreed but warned that if he taught women the lifetime of the sangha would be halved. Even after letting them in, the monastic rules for women were/are much more extensive than for men.

In the modern era, there's still a lot of resistance in traditional Theravadan countries to female nuns. Sri Lanka only started ordaining women in the 1990's, and both Burma and Thailand have jailed nuns in recent history.

One thing you learn being in a Buddhist country, is that there are many buddhists (even monks) engaged in unskillful behavior, just as there are many Christians who don't understand Christ's actual message.

Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by cko on Saturday April 21, 2018 @06:19PM (#16893702)
> First, the Pali canon didn't begin to be put to paper until 100-200 years after the buddha, so like Jesus, there aren't clear first-hand records.

Yes and there are people who suspect that the “Buddha” wasn’t one person, but representative of teachings passed down from a bunch of gurus over the years.

Also, it was the fourth Buddhist council where stuff was written down. That was like 300 years after parinirvana. True to human nature, 70 years after parinirvana the Sangha had already split (second Buddhist council).

And even if there were firsthand records, even if we knew the “actual message”, I’m not sure that really adds much credibility in my mind.

You have an interesting story. Based on you using “skillfull” for “kusala” I assume you’ve read Thanissaro’s translations. Where did you ordain?

Re:Not your Tibetan Buddhism by tombh on Saturday April 21, 2018 @11:04PM (#16894506)
I must unreservedly restate, Buddhism is sexist. This is not a casual statement. I retort that anyone that considers otherwise has not seriously studied Buddhism. There are those who legitimately go even further to say that vast swathes of Buddhism are misogynistic, see Rita Gross' "Buddhism After Patriarchy". This is a very serious matter.